中国制造企业数字化转型模式的质性元分析研究

doi:10.19571/j.cnki.1000-2995.2025.06.003

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 制造企业数字化转型已日益成为学术界和实务界关注的热点，然而由于制造企业数字化转型的复杂性，其转型模式以及实现机理尚处于探索阶段。本文采用质性元分析的方法，拓展并深化了“流程增值-客户增值”双重视角，以53篇研究案例为分析对象，探索中国制造企业不同数字化转型模式的内在机理。研究发现：(1)中国制造企业数字化转型路径包括流程增值和客户增值，企业通过局部数字化、全局数字化与生态数字化的定位和商品主导逻辑与服务主导逻辑的选择开展数字化转型；(2)根据差异化路径组合，制造企业数字化转型模式可分为跃迁型、重构型、渐进型、混合型和颠覆型五种类型；(3)数字化转型模式内在机理可采用“转型情境-行为机制-转型结果”逻辑链予以剖析，不同的市场压力和数字技术压力构成了转型情境，直接影响企业差异化的资源重组机制、制度行动机制、数字创新机制和企业竞争力。本研究拓展了资源编排理论、制度理论和数字创新理论在制造企业不同数字化转型模式中的微观组合机制，对推动制造企业数字化转型的相关理论和实践活动具有启发和指导作用。

关键词: 制造企业, 数字化转型, 转型模式, 质性元分析

Abstract: The digital transformation of manufacturing enterprises has increasingly become a hot spot for both academics and practitioners. Due to the complexity of transformation, the related mode and realization mechanism are still in the exploration stage. Using the method of qualitative meta-analysis and 53 research cases as objects, this paper expanded and deepened the dual perspectives of "process value-added-customer value-added" and explored the internal mechanisms of different digital transformation modes of Chinese manufacturing enterprises. The results showed that: First, the digital transformation consists of two paths, namely process value-added and customer value-added, which are manifested in the positioning of local digitization, global digitization and ecological digitization as well as the choice between goods-dominant logic and service-dominant logic. Second, according to the combination of differentiated paths, the transformation modes can be divided into such five types as leap-over type, reconfiguration type, incremental type, mixed type and disruptive type. Third, the internal mechanism of digital transformation mode can be analyzed by using the logical chain of "transformation context - behavioral mechanism-transformation result". Different digital transformation modes stem from the differentiated resource reorganization mechanism, institutional action mechanism, digital innovation mechanism and transformation results which result from transformation contexts. This study has innovatively extended the micro-combination mechanism of resource orchestration, institutional, and digital innovation theories within diverse digital transformation modes, with its conclusions being instructive and inspiring for both relevant theories and practical endeavors in the digital transformation of manufacturing enterprises.

Key words: manufacturing enterprise, digital transformation, transformation mode, qualitative meta-analysis

程宣梅葛芳婷陈侃翔. 中国制造企业数字化转型模式的质性元分析研究[J]. 科研管理, 2025, 46(6): 21-33.

Cheng Xuanmei, Ge Fangting, Chen Kanxiang. A qualitative meta-analysis study on the digital transformation modes of Chinese manufacturing enterprises[J]. Science Research Management, 2025, 46(6): 21-33.

参考文献

[1]杜勇, 曹磊, 谭畅.平台化如何助力制造企业跨越转型升级的数字鸿沟？——基于宗申集团的探索性案例研究[J].管理世界, 2022, 38(06):117-139
[2]宋华, 陶铮, 杨雨东.“制造的制造”：供应链金融如何使能数字商业生态的跃迁——基于小米集团供应链金融的案例研究[J].中国工业经济, 2022, 0(09):178-196
[3]依绍华, 梁威.传统商业企业如何创新转型——服务主导逻辑的价值共创平台网络构建[J].中国工业经济, 2023, 0(01):171-188
[4]Bartsch S, Weber E, Büttgen M, et al.Leadership matters in crisis-induced digital transformation: how to lead service employees effectively during the COVID-19 pandemic[J].Journal of service management, 2021, 32(1):71-85
[5]Bohnsack R, Kurtz H, Hanelt A.Re-examining path dependence in the digital age: The evolution of connected car business models[J].Research Policy, 2021, 50(9):104328-104328
[6]Lobo S, Whyte J.Aligning and Reconciling: Building project capabilities for digital delivery[J].Research Policy, 2017, 46(1):93-107
[7]Lehrer C, Wieneke A, Brocke J V, et al.How Big Data Analytics Enables Service Innovation: Materiality,Affordance,and the Individualization of Service[J].Journal of Management Information Systems, 2018, 35(2):424-460
[8]Liu Y, Dong J, Ying Y, et al.Status and digital innovation: A middle-status conformity perspective[J]. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 2021, 168:120781.[J].Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 2021, 168(0):120781-120781
[9]Snyder H, Anders G, Paul F, et al.Identifying categories of service innovation: A review and synthesis of the literature[J].Journal of Business Research, 2016, 69(7):2401-2408
[10]王永贵, 汪淋淋.传统企业数字化转型战略的类型识别与转型模式选择研究[J].管理评论, 2021, 33(11):84-93
[11]Jun Jin, Ma L, Ye X.Digital transformation strategies for existed firms:from the perspectives of data ownership and key value propositions[J].Asian Journal of Technology Innovation, 2020, 28(1):77-93
[12]Tekic Z, Koroteev D.From disruptively digital to proudly analog: A holistic typology of digital transformation strategies[J].Business horizons, 2019, 62(6):683-693
[13]Kohtam?ki M, Parida V, Patel P C, et al.The relationship between digitalization and servitization: The role of servitization in capturing the financial potential of digitalization[J].Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 2022, 151(0):119804-119804
[14]Frank A G, Mendes G H S, Ayala N F, et al.Servitization and Industry 4.0 convergence in the digital transformation of product firms: A business model innovation perspective [J].Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 2019, 141(0):341-351
[15]单宇, 许晖, 周连喜, 等.数智赋能：危机情境下组织韧性如何形成？——基于林清轩转危为机的探索性案例研究[J].管理世界, 2021, 37(03):84-104
[16]马赛, 李晨溪.基于悖论管理视角的老字号企业数字化转型研究——以张弓酒业为例[J].中国软科学, 2022, 0(04):184-192
[17]Fitzgerald M, Kruschwitz N, Bonnet D, et al.Embracing digital technology: a new strategic imperative[J].MIT Sloan Management Review, 2014, 55(2):1-1
[18]Nambisan S, Wright M, Feldman M.The digital transformation of innovation and entrepreneurship: Progress,challenges and key themes[J].Research policy, 2019, 48(8):103773-103773
[19]Correani A, De Massis A, Frattini F, et al.Implementing a Digital Strategy: Learning from the Experience of Three Digital Transformation Projects[J].California management review, 2020, 62(4):37-56
[20]余菲菲, 王丽婷.数字技术赋能我国制造企业技术创新路径研究[J].科研管理, 2022, 43(04):11-19
[21]Wimelius H, Mathiassen L, Holmstrm J, et al.A paradoxical perspective on technology renewal in digital transformation[J].Information Systems Journal, 2020, 31(1):198-225
[22]Li J, Li M, Wang X, et al.Strategic directions for ai:the role of cios and boards of directors[J].MIS Quarterly, 2021, 45(3):1603-1643
[23]Raffaelli R, Glynn M A, Tushman M.Frame flexibility: The role of cognitive and emotional framing in innovation adoption by incumbent firms[J].Strategic Management Journal, 2019, 40(7):1013-1039
[24]Mishra A N, Devaraj S, Vaidyanathan G.Capability hierarchy in electronic procurement and procurement process performance: An empirical analysis[J].Journal of Operations Management, 2013, 31(6):376-390
[25]Kannan P K, Li H A.Digital marketing: A framework, review and research agenda[J].International Journal of Research in Marketing, 2017, 34(0):22-25
[26]Andriole S J.Five Myths About Digital Transformation[J].MIT Sloan Management Review, 2017, 58(3):20-22
[27]肖静华, 李文韬.智能制造对企业战略变革与创新的影响——资源基础变革视角的探析[J].财经问题研究, 2020, 0(02):38-46
[28]Peng Y, Tao C.Can digital transformation promote enterprise performance? —From the perspective of public policy and innovation[J].Journal of innovation & knowledge, 2022, 7(3):100198-100198
[29]Llopis-Albert C, Rubio F, Valero F.Impact of digital transformation on the automotive industry[J].Technological Forecasting & Social Change, 2021, 162(0):120343-120343
[30]Amit R, Han X.Value creation through novel resource configurations in a digitally enabled world[J].Strategic Entrepreneurship Journal, 2017, 11(3):228-242
[31]Chen H, Tian Z.Environmental uncertainty, resource orchestration and digital transformation: A fuzzy-set QCA approach[J]. Journal of Business Research, 2022, 139(0):184-193
[32]马鸿佳, 王亚婧, 苏中锋.数字化转型背景下中小制造企业如何编排资源利用数字机会？——基于资源编排理论的fsQCA研究[J].南开管理评论, 2022, 0(0):1-18
[33]Hinings B, Gegenhuber T, Greenwood R.Digital innovation and transformation: An institutional perspective[J].Information and Organization, 2018, 28(1):52-61
[34]应瑛, 张晓杭, 孔小磊, 等.制度视角下的制造企业数字化转型过程：一个纵向案例研究[J].研究与发展管理, 2022, 34(01):8-20
[35]刘洋, 董久钰, 魏江.数字创新管理：理论框架与未来研究[J].管理世界, 2020, 36(07):198-217
[36]Lyytinen K, Yoo Y, Boland R J.Digital Product Innovation Within Four Classes of lnnovation Networks[J].Information Systerms Journal, 2016, 26(1):47-75
[37]Nylén D, Holmstr?m J.Digital Innovation in Context：Exploring Serendipitous and Unbounded Digital Innovation at the Church of Sweden[J].Information Technology and People, 2019, 32(3):696-714
[38]曹裕, 李想, 胡韩莉, 等.数字化如何推动制造企业绿色转型？——资源编排理论视角下的探索性案例研究[J].管理世界, 2023, 39(03):96-112
[39]张培, 董珂隽.制造企业如何实现数据赋能——基于步科数字工厂的案例研究[J].管理案例研究与评论, 2021, 14(06):698-712
[40]Liu Y, Dong J, Mei L, et al.Digital innovation and performance of manufacturing firms: An affordance perspective[J].Technovation, 2023, 119(0):102458-102458
[41]Chandy R K, Tellis G J.The Incumbent's Curse? Incumbency,Size,and Radical Product Innovation[J].Journal of Marketing, 2000, 64(3):1-17
[42]杨蕙馨, 张金艳.颠覆性技术应用何以创造价值优势?——基于商业模式创新视角[J].经济管理, 2019, 41(03):21-37
[43]姜中霜, 王节祥, 李靖华.制造商依托数字技术推进跨越式服务化转型的过程:基于诺力股份的案例研究[J].管理工程学报, 2023, 27(3):212-223
[44]Lusch R F, Nambisan S.Service innovation: a service-dominant logic perspective[J].MIS Quarterly, 2015, 39(1):155-176
[45]肖静华.双跨越———迎战企业数字化转型[EB/OL].https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/BrIO4crkfWlWeDRIjDWr6w, 2020-05-09[Z]. 2020-05-09.
[46]Jafari-Sadeghi V, Garcia-Perez A, Candelo E, et al.Exploring the impact of digital transformation on technology entrepreneurship and technological market expansion: The role of technology readiness, exploration and exploitation[J].Journal of business research, 2021, 124(0):100-111
[47]Kraus S, Durst S, Ferreira J J, et al.Digital transformation in business and management research: An overview of the current status quo[J].International journal of information management, 2022, 63(0):102466-102466
[48]Cheng C, Wang L, Xie H, et al.Mapping digital innovation: A bibliometric analysis and systematic literature review[J].Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 2023, 194(0):122706-122706
[49]Rikard L, Lars M, Lindgren R.Embracing digital innovation in incumbent firms: how volvo cars managed competing concerns[J].MIS Quarterly, 2017, 41(1):239-253
[50]Vial G.Understanding digital transformation: A review and a research agenda[J].The Journal of Strategic Information Systems, 2019, 28(2):118-144
[51]Hoon C.Meta-Synthesis of Oualitative Case Studies : An Approach to Theory Building[J].rganizational Research Methods, 2013, 16(4):522-556
[52]Rauch A, Van Doorn R, Hulsink W.A Qualitative Approach to Evidence-Based Entrepreneurship: Theoretical Considerations and an Example Involving Business Clusters[J].Entrepreneurship: Theory and Practice, 2014, 38(2):333-368
[53]Habersang S, Kueberling-Jost J, Reihlen M, et al.A Process Perspective on Organizational Failure: A Qualitative Meta-Analysis[J].Journal of Management Studies, 2019, 56(1):19-56
[54]陈小梅, 吴小节, 汪秀琼, 等.中国企业逆向跨国并购整合过程的质性元分析研究[J].管理世界, 2021, 37(11):159-183
[55]Eisenhardt K M.Building Theories from Case Study Research[J].Academy of Management Review, 1989, 0(0):0-0
[56]Combs J G, Crook T R, Rauch A.Meta-Analytic Research in Management: Contemporary Approaches,Unresolved Controversies,and Rising Standards[J].Journal of Management Studies, 2019, 56(1):1-18
[57]许晖, 张海军, 冯永春.传承还是重塑? 本土老字号品牌活化模式与机制研究——基于品牌真实性与价值迁移视角[J].管理世界, 2018, 34(04):146-161
[58]Yin R K.Case Study Research: Design and Methods(Vol.5)[M]., Sage, 2009.
[59]赖晓烜, 陈衍泰, 范彦成.制造企业数据驱动动态能力的形成与演化[J].科学学研究, 2023, 41(01):113-122
[60]李春发, 李冬冬, 周驰.数字经济驱动制造业转型升级的作用机理——基于产业链视角的分析[J].商业研究, 2020, 0(02):73-82
[61]Porter M E, Heppelmann J E.How Smart,Connected Products are Transforming Competition[J].Harvard Business Review, 2014, 92(11):64-88
[62]Vargo S L, Lusch R F.Evolving to a new dominant logic for marketing[J].Journal of Marketing, 2004, 68(1):1-17
[63]张峰, 刘曦苑, 武立东, 等.产品创新还是服务转型:经济政策不确定性与制造业创新选择[J].中国工业经济, 2019, 0(07):101-118
[64]杨雅程, 雷家骕, 陈浩, 等.加工制造企业数字化转型的机理——基于资源编排视角的案例研究[J].管理案例研究与评论, 2022, 15(02):198-220
[65]谢康, 吴瑶, 肖静华, 等.组织变革中的战略风险控制——基于企业互联网转型的多案例研究[J].管理世界, 2016, 0(02):133-148
[66]高腾飞, 陈刚, 陈颖.数字服务化视角下的企业管理变革：内在逻辑、动力基础与实践路径[J].贵州社会科学, 2022, 0(02):135-143
[67]王晓明, 沈焱, 张均强, 等.基于制造稳定性的电力装备制造企业柔性制造策略研究[J].中国软科学, 2020, 0(08):122-130
[68]池仁勇, 郑瑞钰, 阮鸿鹏.企业制造过程与商业模式双重数字化转型研究[J].科学学研究, 2022, 40(01):172-181
[69]Kristoffersen E, Blomsma F, Mikalef P, et al.The smart circular economy: A digital-enabled circular strategies framework for manufacturing companies[J].Journal of Business Research, 2020, 120(0):241-261
[70]谢康, 胡杨颂, 刘意, 等.数据要素驱动企业高质量数字化转型——索菲亚智能制造纵向案例研究[J].管理评论, 2023, 35(02):328-339
[71]卢宝周, 尹振涛, 张妍.传统企业数字化转型过程与机制探索性研究[J].科研管理, 2022, 43(04):83-93
[72]陈国权, 王婧懿, 林燕玲.组织数字化转型的过程模型及企业案例研究[J].管理评论, 2021, 33(11):28-42
[73]陈一华, 张振刚, 黄璐.制造企业数字赋能商业模式创新的机制与路径[J].管理学报, 2021, 18(05):731-740
[74]崔淼, 周晓雪.在位企业的能力构建与数字化战略更新：一项质性元分析[J].研究与发展管理, 2021, 33(01):39-52
[75]李晓华.制造业数字化转型与价值创造能力提升[J].改革, 2022, 0(11):24-36
[76]戚聿东, 褚席.数字经济发展、经济结构转型与跨越中等收入陷阱[J].财经研究, 2021, 47(07):18-32
[77]张振刚, 杨玉玲, 陈一华.制造企业数字服务化：数字赋能价值创造的内在机理研究[J].科学学与科学技术管理, 2022, 43(01):38-56
[78]Lounsbury M, Crumley E T.New practice creation: An institutional perspective on innovation[J].Organization Studies, 2007, 28(7):993-1012
[79]吕文晶, 陈劲, 刘进.工业互联网的智能制造模式与企业平台建设——基于海尔集团的案例研究[J].中国软科学, 2019, 0(07):1-13
[80]吴晓波, 张馨月, 沈华杰.商业模式创新视角下我国半导体产业“突围”之路[J].管理世界, 2021, 37(03):123-136
[81]Hanelt A, Bohnsack R, Marz D, et al.A Systematic Review of the Literature on Digital Transformation: Insights and Implications for Strategy and Organizational Change[J].Journal of management studies, 2021, 58(5):1159-1197
[82]刘洋, 李亮.制造企业数字化转型：全球视角与中国故事[J].研究与发展管理, 2022, 34(01):1-7