Evaluation of the sustainability of sharing economy:&nbsp;Social perception and objective performances

DONG Xiao-Song; HUO Yi-Fan; TIAN Xi

PDF(1476 KB)

Science Research Management ›› 2023, Vol. 44 ›› Issue (1) : 79-88.

Evaluation of the sustainability of sharing economy: Social perception and objective performances

Dong Xiaosong¹, Huo Yifan², Zhao Xing³

Author information +

History +

Abstract

As a road to sustainable development, sharing economy has great growth potential and special growth law. However, how to measure and evaluate the sustainability of the sharing economy industry and grasp the law of sustainable development of the sharing economy industry is still very limited. On the one hand, existing studies focus on the external sustainability of individual industries, provinces, cities or countries, ignoring the characteristics of cross-industry, cross-regional, multi-agent participation in the sharing economy, and the sustainability of industry performance in the sharing economy; there is a lack of literature on industry sustainability measurement and evaluation, and there are differences in the effect between the two evaluation paths based on the content of user reviews generated on social media and the actual performance of the industry, which will lead to cognitive dislocation, investment misjudgment and policy failure.

This paper mainly studies the following aspects: (1) systematically combing the current research situation of sharing economy sustainability evaluation at home and abroad; (2) based on social perception and objective performance, using text mining and quantitative analysis to construct the basic framework to measure the sustainability evaluation of multiple industries of sharing economy; and (3) through the online mining of 29771 user evaluation data on social media in China and the collection of industry statistics, we empirically measure the sustainability of the sharing economy industry, compare its differences and explain the reasons.

It is found that the public does not think that the sharing economy industry has significant overall sustainability, and the sustainability of the actual performance of the industry is very different from that of the public. Further, limited by subjective cognitive ability, the public believes that the sustainability of the sharing economy mainly comes from the observable dimensions of the external economy and external ecology of the industry. But objective performance shows that the economic and external technical advantages of the sharing economy industry are the important support for its sustainability. In addition, the difference between the two evaluation is most prominent in the industry where the internal process of capacity sharing such as accommodation and medical treatment is not easy to be observed by the public.

Based on the above conclusions, this paper integrates the process framework of "social perception, objective performance, consistency difference", and provides countermeasures and suggestions for platform enterprises, investors and other stakeholders, government agencies and other subjects, to provide theoretical and practical guidance for the sustainability evaluation of sharing economy. This paper expands the theory of sharing economic sustainability, makes up for the deficiency of evaluation theory, and provides empirical evidence for the cognitive difference of sharing economic sustainability.

Key words

sharing economy / sustainability / social perception / objective performance / consistency

Cite this article

EndNote

Ris (Procite)

Bibtex

Download Citations

Dong Xiaosong, Huo Yifan, Zhao Xing. Evaluation of the sustainability of sharing economy: Social perception and objective performances[J]. Science Research Management. 2023, 44(1): 79-88

References

[1]Martin，J C. The Sharing Economy：A pathway to sustainability or a nightmarish form of neoliberal capitalism?[J]. Ecological Economics，2016，121：149-159.

[2]Heinrichs，H. Sharing economy：A potential new pathway to sustainability[J]. GAIA -Ecological Perspectives for Science and Society，2013，22(4)：228-231.

[3]Hugo，G. Business model diversification in the sharing economy：The case of GoMore[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production，2019.

[4]Belk，R. You are what you can access：Sharing and collaborative consumption online[J]. Journal of Business Research，2014，67(8)：1595-1600.

[5]Zhang，P，Wang，C N. The evolution of social commerce：An examination from the people business，technology and information perspective[J]. Social Science Electronic Publishing，2013.

[6]Elkington，J. Vitality and renewal： A manager's guide for the 21st century[J]. Long Range Planning，1996，29(1).

[7]Elkington，J. Corporate strategy in the chrysalis economy[J]. Corporate Environmental Strategy，2002，9(1).

[8]Leung，X Y，Xue，L and Wen，H. Framing the Sharing Economy：Toward a Sustainable Ecosystem[J]. Tourism Management，2019，71：44-53.

[9]Lee，D H，Park，S Y and Hong，J C. Analysis of the energy and environmental effects of green car deployment by an integrating energy system model with a forecasting model[J]. Applied Energy，2013，103：306-316.

[10]Geng，Y，Fu，J，Sarkis, J and Xue. Towards a national circular economy indicator system in china： An evaluation and critical analysis[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production，2012，23(1)：216-224.

[11]Jones，P， Comfort，D and Bown，R. Sustainable consumption and the UK’s leading retailers[J]. World Review of Entrepreneurship Management and Sustainable Development，2012，6(3)：244-259.

[12]Fearne，A，Martinez M G and Dent B. Dimensions of Sustainable Value Chains：Implications for value chain analysis[J]. Supply Chain Management，2012，17(6)：575-581.

[13]Donateo，T，Ingrosso，F and Licci，F. A method to estimate the environmental impact of an electric city car during six months of testing in an italian city[J]. Journal of Power Sources，2014，270：487-498.

[14]Zervas G，Proserpio D and Byers J. A first look at online reputation on airbnb，where every stay is above average[J]. Social Science Electronic Publishing，2015.

[15]Charlo，M J，Moya，I and Munoz，A M. Sustainable development and corporate financial performance： A study based on the FTSE4Good IBEX Index[J]. Business Strategy and the Environment，2015，24(4)：277-288.

[16]Jeon，C M ，Amekudzi，A A and Guensler，R L. Sustainability assessment at the transportation planning level：performance measures and indexes[J]. Transport Policy，2013，25：10-21.

[17]Hamari，J，Mimmi，S and Ukkonen，A. The Sharing Economy：Why people participate in collaborative consumption[J]. Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology，2016，67.

[18]Kathan，W，Matzler，K and Veider，V. The sharing economy：Your business model's friend or foe?[J]. Business Horizons，2016，59(6)：663-672.

[19]Munoz，P，Cohen，B. Sharing cities and sustainable consumption and production：Towards an integrated framework[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production，2015，134(3)：87-97.

[20]Nina，M，Milena，M. Consumers’ Ethical Perceptions of Social Media Analytics Practices： Risks， benefits and potential outcomes[J]. Journal of Business Research，2019，104.

[21]Eric，B，Benjamin，M M and Theresa，B C. Exploring the empowering and paradoxical relationship between social media and CSR activism[J]. Journal of Business Research，2016，69(8).

[22]Botsman，R，Rogers，R. Beyond Zipcar：Collaborative Consumption[J]. Harvard business Review，2010，88(10).

[23]Bocken，N M P，Short S and Rana P. A literature and practice review to develop sustainable business model archetypes[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production，2014，65：42-56.

[24]Stindt，D. A generic planning approach for sustainable supply chain management——How to integrate concepts and methods to address the issues of sustainability[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production，2017，153：146-163.

[25]Daunorien，A，Drak，A A and Snie，K V. Evaluating sustainability of sharing economy business models[J]. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences，2015，213：836-841.

[26]Geissinger，A，Laure，C，Oberg，C and Sandstrom，C. How sustainable is the sharing economy? on the sustainability connotations of sharing economy platforms[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production，2019.

[27]Plewnia，F，Guenther，E. Mapping the sharing economy for sustainability research[J]. Management Decision，2018，56(3)：570-583.

[28]Bocken，N M P，Short S and Rana P. A value mapping tool for sustainable business modelling[J]. Corporate Governance International Journal of Business in Society，2013，13(5)：482-497.

[29]Ciulli，F，Kolk，A. Incumbents and business model innovation for the sharing economy：Implications for sustainability[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production，2019，214：995-1010.

[30]Wu，X，Zhi，Q. Impact of Shared Economy on Urban Sustainability：From the perspective of social， economic and environmental sustainability[J]. Energy Procedia，2016，104：191-196.

[31]Verboven，H，Vanherck，L. The Sustainability Paradox of the Sharing Economy[J]. uwf UmweltWirtschafts Forum，2016，24(4)：303-314.

[32]Ritter，M，Schanz，H. The sharing economy： A comprehensive business model framework[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production，2019，213：320-331.

[33]Kumar，V，Lahiri，A and Dogan，O B. A strategic framework for a profitable business model in the sharing economy[J]. Industrial Marketing Management，2018，69：147-160.

[34]Guyadera，H，Piscicelli，L. Business model diversification in the sharing economy：The case of Gomore[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production，2019.

[35]Ancarani，A. Supplier evaluation in local public services：Application of a model of value for customer[J]. Journal of Purchasing & Supply Management，2009，15(1)：33-42.

[36]Kleinberg，J. The Convergence of Social and Technological Networks[J]. Communications of the ACM，2008，51(11)：66.

[37]Lane N D，Miluzzo E and Lu H. A Survey of Mobile Phone Sensing[J]. IEEE Communications Magazine，2010，48(9)：140-150.

[38]潘晓波，黄卫来，蔡淑琴. 反转负面追加评价与在线消费者态度矛盾性[J]. 科研管理，2017，38(04)：104-112.

[39]Liu，Y，Liu，X and Gao，S. Social sensing：A new approach to understanding our socioeconomic environments[J]. Annals of the Association of American Geographers，2015，105(3)：512-530.

[40]Bellotti，V，Back，M and Edwards，W K. Making Sense of Sensing Systems：Five questions for designers and researchers[J]. Proceedings of the CHI 2002 Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems： Changing our World, Changing ourselves，Minneapolis，Minnesota，USA，2002，April 20-25.

[41]Eagle，N，Pentland，A. Reality mining：Sensing complex social systems[J]. Personal and Ubiquitous Computing，2006，10(4)：255-268.

[42]Miluzzo，E，Lane，N D and Eisenman，S B. Cenceme-Injecting sensing presence into social networking applications[J]. Lecture Notes in Computer Science，2007，4793：1-28.

[43]Provasnek，A K，Schmid，E and Geissler，B. Sustainable corporate entrepreneurship：Performance and strategies toward innovation[J]. Business Strategy and the Environment，2017，26(4)：521-535.

[44]汪会玲，吴梦颖. 基于社会网络分析的我国家庭旅馆评价模型构建[J].管理学报，2015，12(03)：433-438.

Wang Huiling, Wu Mengying. Construction of family hotel evaluation model in china based on social network analysis [J]. Journal of Management，2015，12(03)：433-438.

[45]Smith，T W，Axon，C J and Darton，R C. A methodology for measuring the sustainability of car transport systems[J]. Transport Policy，2013，30：308-317.

[46]宋傅天,卫平,姚东旻.共享经济的统计测度:界定、困境与展望[J].统计研究,2018,35(05):38-49.

[47]景维民，裴伟东.国家共享水平测度——中国与发达国家的比较[J]. 社会科学，2019(07)：31-42.

[48]唐谷文，王能民，张萌. 企业绿色增长指标体系设计与评价[J]. 科研管理，2019，40(07)：47-58.

[49]颜莉.我国区域创新效率评价指标体系实证研究[J]. 管理世界，2012(05)：174-175.

[50]Oestreicher，G，Zalmanson，L. Content or community? A digital business strategy for content providers in the social age[J]. MIS Quarterly，2013，37(2)：591-616.

[51]Stieglitz，S，Linh，D X，Bruns，A and Neuberger，C. Social media analytics[J]. Business & Information Systems Engineering，2014，6(2)：89-96.

[52]Allem，J P，Uppu，S P，Boley，C T and Unger，J B. Characterizing swisher little cigar-related posts on twitter in 2018:Text analysis[J]. Journal of Medical Internet Research，2019，21(7).

[53]Wang，X Q，Yuen，K F，Wong，Y D，Li，K X. How can the maritime industry meet sustainable development goals? An analysis of sustainability reports from the social entrepreneurship perspective[J]. Transportation Research Part D，2020，78.

[54]白俊红，江可申，李婧，林雷芳.企业技术创新能力测度与评价的因子分析模型及其应用[J]. 中国软科学，2008(03)：108-114.

[55]Peter，J，Daphne，C and David，H. Marketing sustainable consumption within stores： A case study of the UK’s leading food retailers[J]. Sustainability，2009，1(4)：815-826.

[56]林海明，杜子芳. 主成分分析综合评价应该注意的问题[J]. 统计研究，2013，30(08)：25-31.