Science Research Management ›› 2022, Vol. 43 ›› Issue (5): 34-43.

Previous Articles     Next Articles

Research on the implementation effect of "innovation and entrepreneurship" series policies in China: A study from the perspective of policy mix effect

Tang Linjia1, Mei Zi2, Guo Yuanyuan1   

  1. 1. China Institute for Small and Medium Enterprise, Zhejiang University of Technology, Hangzhou 310023, Zhejiang, China;
    2. School of Management, Zhejiang University of Technology, Hangzhou 310023, Zhejiang, China
  • Received:2020-03-17 Revised:2020-09-11 Online:2022-05-20 Published:2022-05-20

Abstract:     The "Innovation and Entrepreneurship" series policies ("I&E series policies") in China are a set of complex policy systems formulated and implemented under specific themes. This paper uses the policy mixture effect to explain the effectiveness of series policies. We try to find out the types of efficient policy mix and provide references for policy makers. Based on the literature reviews, we conclude the policy mix effect into three dimensions, which are named as the policy tool mix effect, the policy area mix effect and the policy time mix effect. These three policy mix effects may better explain how the I&E series policies are working as  combination and come to be an efficient policy outcome, including both higher level of innovation intensity and entrepreneurial involvement.
    This paper collects 156 "Innovation and Entrepreneurship" policies in China from the year of 2009 to 2018, and uses the text analysis method to quantify the collected policy texts from four dimensions: policy tool, policy goal, policy detail and policy continuity. Then we explore the policy mix effect by using the method of fuzzy set Qualitative Comparative Analysis (fsQCA). The results show that there are three kinds of policy mixtures that lead to high level of policy effectiveness, which are named as environmental-balanced type, supply-push type and demand-pull type. These three paths are separately matched with the developed and developing areas in China, which are generally divided as the eastern, central and western regions of China. 
    The policy mix effect is mainly reflected in the following aspects: (1) In all effective configurations, three types of policy tools are used in a balanced way, and the combination of supply and demand-based policy tools accounts for a large proportion. The superposition of two or more policy tools can improve the policy effectiveness. In addition, the combination of policy tools, innovation and entrepreneurship goals can be considered as the motivation of innovation and entrepreneurship. (2) The effective configurations vary in different regions of China, and the policy differentiation supply should be realized in different developing and developed areas. In particular, for enterprises in the eastern region, the policy should focus on providing a continuous and stable business environment; For the central region, policy makers should pay attention to pulling up the demand and stimulating the market vitality; For the western region, the key work is about supply promotion, such as financial support, talent introduction, etc., When making policies, we should set clear policy objectives and strive to promote the coordinated development of the western region. (3) Attention should be paid to the different configurations of policy continuity when considering the policy mix effect throughout the time, and specific policies need to be implemented according to different policy tools and applicable regions. Specifically, if all three kinds of policy tools are used in combination, they should be continued with similar policies in recent years. On the other hand, if we focus on a certain type of policy tool or a specific policy goal, the previous policies should not be over repeated and relied on. This study provides new ideas for the formulation, implementation and evaluation of national series policies.

Key words:  policy evaluation;entrepreneurship and innovation, series policies;policy mix effect, fsQCA