Science Research Management ›› 2020, Vol. 41 ›› Issue (4): 11-22.

Previous Articles     Next Articles

Integrity culture and corporate innovation

Tang Wei1,2, Cai Wenjing3, Cui Yeguang4   

  1. 1. School of Accounting, Anhui University of Finance and Economic, Bengbu 233030, Anhui, China;
    2. School of Business, Renmin University of China, Beijing 100872, China;
    3. School of International Business, University of International Business and Economics,Beijing 100029, China;
    4. School of Accounting, Capital University of Economics and Business,Beijing 100070, China
  • Received:2018-04-03 Revised:2018-08-19 Online:2020-04-20 Published:2020-04-21

Abstract: Corporate culture has great influence on corporate performance. On the one hand, corporate culture can shape the driving force of the company. According to the Enterprise Resource Theory, the heterogeneous resources owned or controlled by enterprises, which are valuable, scarce and difficult to be imitated and replaced, determine the competitive advantage and sustainable development of enterprises. Corporate culture is heterogeneous resource which is unique and hard to be imitated and copied within the enterprise, which is the core "driving force" of enterprise development; on the other hand, corporate culture shapes corporate cohesion. Corporate culture is the "soul" in the development of enterprises. As a soft system constraint, corporate culture can improve corporate performance by directly influencing the values and behavior of organizational employees and reduce the coordination cost of management strategy. Enterprise performance is an output of quality and efficiency, which has a multi-dimensional structure, covering short-term profitability, market value, innovation ability and international market performance. The innovative behavior of enterprises is endogenous from the institutional environment. Look through the previous literatures, we can find that most of experts pay more attention to the impact of formal system(such as legal system, marketization process, government regulation, etc.), while the impact of informal system, such as culture and religion, on enterprise innovation is less studied. As for China, which is in the transition period, the formal system is becoming more and more perfect but is still lacking. It may has more practical significances to study the innovation of enterprises from the perspective of informal system. "Integrity" culture as the core of corporate culture is the foundation of enterprise management, which helps to attract investment, reduce transaction costs, improve operation efficiency, and thereby improve enterprise performance. However, throughout the existing research results,we can find that there is no corresponding empirical evidence to support the view that "Integrity"-oriented corporate culture can promote the improvement of corporate innovation capabilities.In view of this, this paper attempts to examine the effect of "integrity" culture on corporate innovation, and then provides empirical evidence from another dimension for the influence of corporate culture on enterprise performance. Firstly, the "integrity" culture has positive externalities. As a kind of signal transmission, "integrity" culture can reduce information asymmetry and moral hazard in market transactions, and effectively improve the business credit level of enterprises. At the same time, "honest" enterprises have higher credit ratings, are easier to obtain bank loans, and are more favored by capital market investors, all of which help enterprises obtain financing facilities and alleviate the shortage of funds in the research and development process. Secondly, the culture of "integrity" affects corporate behavior. On the one hand, "integrity" culture has the function of behavior guidance and restraint. "Integrity", as an internalized code of conduct for enterprises, opposes the selfish opportunistic behavior, which will reduce the self-interested motivation of enterprise managers and help alleviate agency problems in innovation activities. On the other hand, the value culture with "integrity" as the core can enhance enterprises′ sense of social responsibility, drive enterprises to be willing to invest more in technology, research and development, and enhance their awareness of independent innovation. Finally, the psychological view holds that positive emotional experiences promote individual behavior. In the positive emotional atmosphere shaped by the "integrity" culture, enterprise R&D personnel are more active in their innovative thinking, and at the same time, they can better contribute to the implementation of innovation and promote enterprise innovation.This paper holds that enterprises that emphasize "integrity" culture have stronger innovation ability. Furthermore, from the perspective of institutional background, under the guidance and edification of Confucianism for thousands of years in China, the informal system has been highly praised, especially still in the emerging stage of imperfect formulation and implementation of the formal system in China, where the status of the informal system is more important. Therefore, when the enterprise is in the adverse situation, that is, when the formal system is in a poor environment, the role of the informal system such as culture will be more prominent, or there is an alternative role for the formal system. At the micro level, the difference of the nature of the enterprise and the governance structure may lead to the heterogeneity of the influence of the "integrity" culture on the innovation of the enterprise. For this reason,this paper effectively identifies the integrity-oriented corporate culture data through the text analysis approach and empirically analyzes the relationship between integrity culture and corporate innovation using a sample of A-share listed firms at Shanghai and Shenzhen Stock Exchanges from 2007 to 2015. And we further examine the difference of this influence from the perspective of the micro-level corporate characteristics and macro-level institutional environment. The empirical results show that firms that treat "integrity" as their primary culture have more patent applications and stronger innovation ability; further study finds that the “drive” effects of "integrity" culture on corporate innovation are stronger for state-owned enterprises, firms whose board chairman also serves as a CEO, and firms that are located in poor-institution areas.The research contributions of this paper are as follows: First, by examining the influence of "integrity" culture on the innovation ability of enterprises, this paper enriches the literature of the antecedent fields of R&D and innovation, and expands the understanding of the economic consequences of corporate culture; Second,by examining the regulatory role of macro environmental factors and micro enterprise characteristics in enterprise management, the paper can make people have a deeper understanding of the effect of corporate culture on corporate performance; Third, under the current predicament of the lack of endogenous power development of China′s real economy, this paper explains the promotion path of Chinese enterprises′ innovation ability from the perspective of universal culture, which has important practical value.

Key words: integrity, innovation ability, corporate nature, duality, institutional environment