短视频个性化推荐对用户信息采纳意愿的影响

张生太, 杨阳, 袁艺玮, 杨洪军, 张梦桃

科研管理 ›› 2024, Vol. 45 ›› Issue (4) : 175-184.

PDF(1121 KB)
PDF(1121 KB)
科研管理 ›› 2024, Vol. 45 ›› Issue (4) : 175-184. DOI: 10.19571/j.cnki.1000-2995.2024.04.019

短视频个性化推荐对用户信息采纳意愿的影响

作者信息 +

Influence of personalized recommendation of short-videos on users' information adoption intention

Author information +
文章历史 +

摘要

“抖音5分钟,人间1小时”,近年来短视频社交平台成为用户获取信息和日常娱乐的重要途径之一,受到了学术界的广泛关注。然而,少有学者结合短视频平台特点,深入研究抖音等短视频用户对平台技术的感知和理解及其对用户心理需求和行为模式的影响,关于感知个性化和信息窄化的影响也未在抖音等短视频平台上得到验证。本文以抖音为例,借鉴刺激-机体-反应(S-O-R)模型,对用户感知个性化、信息窄化、心理抗拒对信息采纳意愿的影响进行了实证研究。结果显示,用户感知个性化会对信息窄化产生积极影响,感知个性化程度高的用户更容易陷入“信息茧房”中。其次,与以往研究不同,本研究发现用户感知个性化和信息窄化会降低用户的心理抗拒。该结果表明,短视频平台中,高水平的个性化推荐会降低用户的信息获取成本和平台使用成本,提高用户的满意度。最后,本研究发现心理抗拒在两条影响路径中均起到了部分中介的作用,表明用户对平台算法的感知会通过降低心理抗拒来提高信息采纳意愿。本研究从研究情境、研究变量及研究模型上拓宽了信息采纳意愿的研究领域。由研究结果可知,在探究用户对抖音等短视频平台的感知个性化和信息窄化时,不能完全借鉴以往结论,需单独研究。本研究为平台管理者进一步改善推荐算法提供理论支撑,也为传播界避免“劣币驱逐良币”现象产生提供了新的研究视角。

Abstract

"Five minutes on TikTok, one hour on earth"! In recent years, the academia has focused a lot of attention on short-video social networks, which have become one of the most important sources of information and daily entertainment for users. Few academics, however, have examined in-depth how TikTok and other short-video viewers perceive and understand the platform technology and how this influences the users' psychological requirements and behavioral patterns. When using the TikTok platform, users' information behavior is primarily that of information adoption. However, there is currently relatively little research on how likely users are to adopt the information on platforms for short-videos, like TikTok. It is unclear whether the distinctive features of short-video sites like TikTok will have a different effect. Second, one of the key features of short-video platforms like TikTok is in the form of personalized recommendation. According to some academics, users will be less ready to adopt information if perceived customization is too strong. On the platforms for short-videos like TikTok, nevertheless, this conclusion has not been tested. It has not been investigated whether perceived personalization will affect users' psychological resistance or negative psychology. Finally, there are still some conflicts and contradictions in the current research on the impact of information narrowing, and it is necessary to further verify the impact of information narrowing. The impact of perceived personalization and information narrowing for short-videos, such as TikTok, has also not been established. To seek reasonable solutions to these issues, this study empirically examined the information adoption intention of users of short-video platforms by using TikTok as an illustration, and using the Stimulus-Organism-Response (S-O-R) model.
In this study, the primary data collection method used is questionnaire surveys. The measurement of relevant variables mainly adopted the currently available relevant scales, and the Likert five-level scale was used as the measurement tool. A total of 480 questionnaires were collected, and 435 valid questionnaires were obtained after eliminating some invalid ones. Our hypotheses were essentially confirmed by analyzing the data obtained from the questionnaires. First, the findings demonstrated that perceived personalization benefits information narrowing. Contrary to other studies, this one discovered that perceived personalization lowers the psychological resistance among users and raises their intention to adopt new information. Users' perceived personalization and information adoption intention do not interact nonlinearly. In contrast to earlier studies, it was also found that information narrowing also lowers users' psychological resistance and raises their intention to adopt new information. The impacts of perceived personalization and information narrowing on information adoption intention are partially mediated by psychological resistance.
By introducing a new research setting, new research variables, and new research model, this study broadened the study of information adoption intention. The findings of the study showed that it is not viable to completely depend on earlier research when examining users' perceptions of personalization on short-video platforms like TikTok and that further research is necessary. This study enriched the research field of perceptual personalization and provided some reference for other scholars to explore the perceptual personalization of users on short-video platforms such as TikTok. Besides, this study adopted the quantitative way to further verify the existence of information narrowing. As for the variable of information narrowing, this study's findings differ from those of earlier studies, which offers a fresh theoretical foundation and new support for related research in this field. The findings of the study demonstrate that "Information Cocoons" is directly tied to user psychology as well as the algorithms used for short-video recommendations and other applications. The phenomena of "Bad money drives out good" in the communication sphere must therefore be avoided through the combined efforts of platform managers, news media and readers. In order to further strengthen recommendation algorithms and customer satisfaction, platform management should pay close attention to the findings of this study.

关键词

短视频 / 信息采纳意愿 / 信息窄化 / 感知个性化 / 心理抗拒

Key words

short-video / information adoption intention / information narrowing / perceived personalization / psychological reactance

引用本文

导出引用
张生太, 杨阳, 袁艺玮, . 短视频个性化推荐对用户信息采纳意愿的影响[J]. 科研管理. 2024, 45(4): 175-184 https://doi.org/10.19571/j.cnki.1000-2995.2024.04.019
Zhang Shengtai, Yang Yang, Yuan Yiwei, et al. Influence of personalized recommendation of short-videos on users' information adoption intention[J]. Science Research Management. 2024, 45(4): 175-184 https://doi.org/10.19571/j.cnki.1000-2995.2024.04.019
中图分类号: G203,G206.3   

参考文献

[1]
张彬, 崔海兰, 单思远, 等. 短视频平台用户持续使用意愿影响因素研究:以健康短视频为例[J]. 图书馆研究, 2023, 53(2):97-109.
ZHANG Bin, CUI Hailan, SHAN Siyuan, et al. Research on the influential factors of users' continuance intention towards short video platforms: Taking health short videos as an example[J]. Library Research, 2023, 53(2):97-109.
[2]
叶凤云, 白佼璐, 李君君. 短视频用户偶遇信息分享行为影响因素研究[J]. 情报理论与实践, 2023, 46(10):121-129.
YE Fengyun, BAI Jiaolu, LI Junjun. Research on influencing factors of short video users' encounter information sharing behavior[J]. Information Studies: Theory & Application, 2023, 46(10):121-129.
[3]
MA X, SUN Y, GUO X, et al. Understanding users' negative responses to recommendation algorithms in short-video platforms: A perspective based on the Stressor-Strain-Outcome (SSO) framework[J]. Electronic Markets, 2022, 32(8):41-58.
[4]
ZHANG X, WU Y, LIU S. Exploring short-form video application addiction: Socio-technical and attachment perspectives[J]. Telematics and Informatics, 2019, 42(9):101243.1-101243.15.
[5]
ZHAO Z. Analysis on the “Douyin Tiktok Mania” phenomenon based on recommendation algorithms[J]. E3S Web of Conference, 2021, 235:03-029.
[6]
沈雨筱, 纪雪梅, 王芳. 政务短视频内容娱乐化对用户信息采纳效果的影响研究[J]. 现代情报, 2023, 43(7):85-95.
摘要
[目的/意义] 政务短视频对娱乐化程度的把握成为新媒体环境下政务信息公开中亟需关注的问题,研究政务短视频娱乐化特征及其对公众信息采纳效果的影响,能为政务短视频信息公开方式优化提供理论参考。[方法/过程] 首先构建政务短视频娱乐化评价指标体系,然后探究政务短视频娱乐化对用户信息采纳效果的影响,最后对政务短视频的信息公开方式提出针对性建议。[结果/结论] 用户信息采纳效果随政务短视频娱乐化程度的增强呈现先提升后降低的趋势,政务短视频在词语运用、多媒体手段融合、标签运用、情绪表达、话题娱乐性以及政府职能体现程度方面均体现出娱乐化特征,并影响用户信息采纳效果。
SHEN Yuxiao, JI Xuemei, WANG Fang. Research on the entertainment characteristics of government short videos and their influences on users' information adoption[J]. Journal of Modern Information, 2023, 43(7):85-95.
[7]
宋雪雁, 王萍. 信息采纳行为概念及影响因素研究[J]. 情报科学, 2010, 28(5):760-762+767.
SONG Xueyan, WANG Ping. Research on concept and effective factors of information adoption behavior[J]. Information Science, 2010, 28(5):760-762+767.
[8]
李义刚, 李海刚. 创新社区成员参与行为与组织采纳的关系研究[J]. 科研管理, 2016, 37(S1):309-317.
LI Yigang, LI Haigang. A research on the relationship between members' participation behavior and organizational adoption in innovation communities from the social network perspective[J]. Science Research Management, 2016, 37(S1):309-317.
[9]
SUSSMAN S W, SIEGAL W S. Informational influence in organizations: An integrated approach to knowledge adoption[J]. Information Systems Research, 2003, 14(1):47-65.
This research investigates how knowledge workers are influenced to adopt the advice that they receive in mediated contexts. The research integrates the Technology Acceptance Model (Davis 1989) with dual-process models of informational influence (e.g., Petty and Cacioppo 1986, Chaiken and Eagly 1976) to build a theoretical model of information adoption. This model highlights the assessment of information usefulness as a mediator of the information adoption process. Importantly, the model draws on the dual-process models to make predictions about the antecedents of informational usefulness under different processing conditions.
[10]
刘春明, 郝庆升, 周杨, 等. 电商平台中绿色农产品消费者信息采纳行为及影响因素研究:基于信息生态视角[J]. 情报科学, 2019, 37(7):151-157.
摘要
【目的/意义】随着电子商务的快速发展,消费者从电子商务平台购买商品已经成为习惯,研究影响绿色农 产品消费者信息采纳行为的因素及其作用关系,对于推动绿色农产品网络消费有着积极的作用。【方法/过程】本文 在绿色农产品电商平台信息采纳行为理论研究基础上,构建信息采纳行为理论模型并通过实证检验绿色农产品电 商平台信息采纳行为影响因素的作用关系。【结果/结论】信息感知有用性、信息人满意度、平台环境安全性、平台信 息技术对电商平台中绿色农产品消费者信息采纳意愿产生正向影响。而信息采纳意向对信息采纳行为产生正向 影响,其中信息采纳意愿是信息采纳行为的中介变量。
LIU Chunming, HAO Qingsheng, ZHOU Yang, et al. Consumer information acceptance behavior and influencing factors of green agricultural products in E-commerce platform: In the perspective of information ecology[J]. Information Science, 2019, 37(7):151-157.
[11]
蒋骁, 季绍波, 仲秋雁. 电子政务服务公民采纳模型及实证研究[J]. 科研管理, 2011, 32(1):129-136+146.
JIANG Xiao, JI Shaobo, ZHONG Qiuyan, Citizen adoption of E-government services: An empirical study[J]. Science Research Management, 2011, 32(1):129-136+146.
[12]
韩世曦, 曾粤亮. 突发公共卫生事件背景下数字青年微信公众平台健康信息采纳意愿影响因素研究[J]. 图书馆学研究, 2021(06):83-92.
HAN Shixi, ZENG Yueliang. Study on the factors influencing the willingness to adopt health information on WeChat public platform for digital youth in the context of public health emergencies[J]. Research on Library Science, 2021(06):83-92.
[13]
陈媛, 郭沫含. 移动短视频UGC信息流广告用户采纳意愿影响因素研究[J]. 图书情报导刊, 2021, 6(11):25-32.
CHEN Yuan, GUO Mohan. Research on influence factors of users' adoption intention on user-generated content of mobile video clips of news feed ads[J]. Journal of Library and Information Science, 2021, 6(11):25-32.
[14]
LI C. When does web-based personalization really work? The distinction between actual personalization and perceived personalization[J]. Computers in Human Behavior, 2016, 54(1):25-33.
[15]
MALHEIROS M, JENNETT C, PATEL S, et al. Too close for comfort: A study of the effectiveness and acceptability of rich media personalized advertising[C]. Proceedings of Conference on Human Factors in Computing System, 2012:579-588.
[16]
吕巍, 杨颖, 张雁冰. AI个性化推荐下消费者感知个性化对其点击意愿的影响[J]. 管理科学, 2020, 33(5):44-57.
LYU Wei, YANG Ying, ZHANG Yanbing. Effects of consumers' perceived personalization on their click-through intention under AI personalized recommendations[J]. Journal of Management Science, 2020, 33(5):44-57.
[17]
孙瑞英. 网络信息窄化的心理学解析[J]. 情报科学, 2010, 28(11):1625-1629.
SUN Ruiying. Psychological analysis of information narrowing in network environment[J]. Information Science, 2010, 28(11):1625-1629.
[18]
杜娟, 游静. “信息茧房”效应下消费者对个性化推送的采纳意愿研究:心理抗拒视角[J]. 企业经济, 2019(1):103-110.
DU Juan, YOU Jing. Consumers' adoption of personalized pushing under the "information cocoon" effect: A psychological resistance perspective[J]. Enterprise Economy, 2019(1):103-110.
[19]
VAN DOORN J, HOEKSTRA J C. Customization of online advertising: The role of intrusiveness[J]. Marketing Letters, 2013, 24(4):339-351.
[20]
MEHRABIAN A, RUSSELL J A. An approach to environmental psychology[M]. Cambridge: MIT, 1974.
[21]
贾明霞, 熊回香. 虚拟学术社区知识交流与知识共享探究:基于整合S-O-R模型与MOA理论[J]. 图书馆学研究, 2020(2):43-54.
JIA Mingxia, XIONG Huixiang. An exploration of knowledge exchange and knowledge sharing in virtual academic communities:Based on integrating S-O-R model and MOA theory[J]. Research on Library Science, 2020(2):43-54.
[22]
龚艳萍, 曹玉, 李见. 短视频应用的特性对用户参与行为的影响:心理参与的中介作用[J]. 情报科学, 2020, 38(7):77-84.
摘要
 【目的】越来越多的人使用短视频APP观看短视频和参与短视频的制作和分享。然而,鲜有文献探究短视频应用用户参与行为的驱动因素。因此,研究从平台的视角,基于刺激-有机体-反应(SOR)模型,以使用用户为研究对象,探究短视频应用的享乐属性和社交属性对用户参与行为的影响及作用机制。【方法/过程】研究通过问卷调查法,收集有效数据245份。【结果/结论】实证结果表明短视频APP的娱乐性、原创性、个性化和社交化皆显著正向影响用户的心理参与,娱乐性、原创性、个性化通过心理参与显著影响用户参与行为,亚文化直接显著影响用户参与行为。
GONG Yanping, CAO Yu, LI Jian. The impact of short-video application characteristics on user engagement behavior: The mediating role of psychological engagement[J]. Information Science, 2020, 38(7):77-84.
[23]
ZANKER M, RICCI F, JANNACH D, et al. Measuring the impact of personalization and recommendation on user behavior[J]. International Journal of Human Computer Studies, 2010, 68(8):469-471.
[24]
SUNSTEIN C R. Republic.com[M]. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2001.
[25]
HUANG Y, ZHOU L, ZENG Z, et al. An empirical study on the phenomenon of information narrowing in the context of personalized recommendation[C]. Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 2020, 1631(1):012109.
[26]
吴丹, 樊舒. 信息行为领域选择性暴露研究:视角、方法、动向[J]. 图书情报知识, 2020(1):32-41.
WU Dan, FAN Shu. Selective exposure in the field of information behavior: Perspective method and trend[J]. Documentation, Information & Knowledge, 2020(1):32-41.
[27]
朱宏淼, 张生太, 闫辛. 微信群中隐性知识传播模型研究[J]. 科研管理, 2019, 40(2):106-115.
ZHU Hongmiao, ZHANG Shengtai, YAN Xin. A study of the tacit knowledge transmission model in a WeChat group[J]. Science Research Management, 2019, 40(2):106-115.
[28]
范钧, 关潇汇, 陈婷婷. 您喜欢电商平台的“猜您喜欢”吗?:个性化推荐对在线消费者心理抗拒的影响机制[J]. 财经论丛, 2020(4): 84-93.
摘要
运用心理抗拒和两阶段决策理论,通过三个2×2实验,分析电商平台个性化推荐时机、方式和契合度对消费者心理抗拒的影响机制。研究发现:浏览阶段采用基于隐式反馈的推荐更易引发感知操纵意图和感知隐私侵犯,决策阶段采用基于显式反馈的推荐更易引发感知操纵意图和感知隐私侵犯;推荐契合度较高时,决策阶段的推荐和基于隐式反馈的推荐更易引发感知操纵意图和感知隐私侵犯;推荐契合度较低时,浏览阶段的推荐更易引发感知操纵意图和感知隐私侵犯,基于显式反馈的推荐更易引发感知操纵意图,基于隐式反馈的推荐更易引发感知隐私侵犯;感知操纵意图和感知隐私侵犯对心理抗拒有显著正向影响。
FAN Jun, GUAN Xiaohui, CHEN Tingting. Do you like the "guess you like" on the E-commerce platform? Effect of personalized recommendation on online consumers' psychological reactance[J]. Collected Essays on Finance and Economics, 2020(4): 84-93.
[29]
BREHM J W. A theory of psychological reactance[M]. Oxford, England: Academic Press, 1966.
[30]
YOUN S, KIM S. Understanding ad avoidance on Facebook: Antecedents and outcomes of psychological reactance[J]. Computers in Human Behavior, 2019, 98:232-244.
[31]
CHEN J V, TRAN A, NGUYEN T. Understanding the discontinuance behavior of mobile shoppers as a consequence oftechnostress: An application of the stress-coping theory[J]. Computers in Human Behavior, 2019, 95:83-93.
[32]
王松, 王瑜, 李芳. 社会化电子商务情境下信息过载对用户消极使用行为的影响:基于倦怠和抗拒的中介[J]. 企业经济, 2019, 38(3):50-57.
WANG Song, WANG Yu, LI Fang. Information overload in social E-commerce contexts impact on users' negative usage behavior:Mediation based on burnout and resistance[J]. Enterprise Economy, 2019, 38(3):50-57.
[33]
LEE T. The impact of perceptions of interactivity on customer trust and transaction intentions in mobile commerce[J]. Journal of Electronic Commerce Research, 2005, 21(2):328-339.
[34]
SITTENTHALER S, TRAUT MATTAUSCH E, STEINDL C, et al. Salzburger state reactance scale (SSR Scale)[J]. Zeitschrift Fur Psychologie, 2015, 223(4):257-266.
[35]
VENKATESH V. Determinants of perceived ease of use: Integrating perceived behavioral control, computer anxiety and enjoyment into the technology acceptance model[J]. Information Systems Research, 2000, 4(11):342-365.
[36]
HARMAN H. Modern factor analysis[M]. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1967:67-70.
[37]
黎常, 金杨华. 科技伦理视角下的人工智能研究[J]. 科研管理, 2021, 42(8):9-16.
LI Chang, JIN Yanghua. A research on artificial intelligence from the perspective of science and technology ethics[J]. Science Research Management, 2021, 42(8):9-16.
[38]
师斌, 李凯, 严建援. 基于隐私视角的LBS用户使用意向研究[J]. 科研管理, 2018, 39(4): 64-73.
SHI Bin, LI Kai, YAN Jianyuan. A research on LBS users' intentions based on the perspective of privacy[J]. Science Research Management, 2018, 39(4): 64-73.
[39]
MOU X B, XU F, DU J T. Examining the factors influencing college students' continuance intention to use short-form video APP[J]. Aslib Journal of Information Management, 2021, 73(6): 992-1013.
The purpose of this study is to explore the effects of recommendation algorithm, product reputation, new product novelty, privacy concern and privacy protection behavior on users’ satisfaction and continuance intention to use short-form video application (APP).
[40]
温忠麟, 叶宝娟. 中介效应分析:方法和模型发展[J]. 心理科学进展, 2014, 22(5):731-745.
摘要
在心理学和其他社科研究领域, 大量实证文章建立中介效应模型, 以分析自变量对因变量的影响过程和作用机制。检验中介效应最流行的方法是Baron和Kenny的逐步法, 但近年来不断受到批评和质疑, 有人甚至呼吁停止使用其中的依次检验, 改用目前普遍认为比较好的Bootstrap法直接检验系数乘积。本文对相关的议题做了辨析, 并讨论了中介分析中建立因果关系的方法。综合新近的研究成果, 总结出一个中介效应分析流程, 并分别给出显变量和潜变量Mplus程序。最后介绍了中介效应模型的发展。
WEN Zhonglin, YE Baojuan. Analyses of mediating effects: The development of methods and models[J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 2014, 22(5):731-745.
<p>Mediation models are frequently used in the research of psychology and other social science disciplines. Mediation indicates that the effect of an independent variable on a dependent variable is transmitted through a third variable, which is called mediator. In most applied research, Baron and Kenny&rsquo;s (1986) causal steps approach has been used to test mediating effect. In recent years, however, many methodological researchers questioned the rationality of the causal steps approach, and some of them even attempted to stop its use. Firstly, we clarify the queries on the causal steps approach one by one. Secondly, we propose a new procedure to analyze mediating effects. The new procedure is better than any single method that constitutes the procedure in terms of Type I error rate and power. The proposed procedure can be conducted by using observed variables and/or latent variables. Mplus programs are supplied for the procedure with observed variables and/or latent variables. Finally, this article introduces the development of mediation models, such as mediation model of ordinal variables, multilevel mediation, multiple mediation, moderated mediation, and mediated moderation.</p>

基金

国家自然科学基金项目:“移动社交网络微信的知识传播机理研究”(71571022)
国家自然科学基金项目:“移动社交网络微信的知识传播机理研究”(2015.01—2019.12)

PDF(1121 KB)

Accesses

Citation

Detail

段落导航
相关文章

/