区域军民科技协同创新是推动军民深度融合发展的必然选择,亦是践行创新驱动发展战略的现实需求。本研究基于创新生态系统视角,剖析了区域军民科技协同创新生态系统的特征和演化机理,构建了以军工企业、民口企业和地方政府为关键创新主体的演化博弈模型,并以黑龙江省为例开展了数值仿真。研究表明:(1)合理的成本分担情况下,即使地方政府不直接介入协同创新,两者仍会选择继续合作开展科技协同创新。(2)公平的利益分配有利于促进军民企业协作,利益分配极端失衡的情况下,政府倾向于直接介入协同创新以维持系统稳定。(3)地方政府是否进行财政补贴以及补贴力度强弱不会对军民企业协同创新演化方向产生根本性影响,但适当的财政补贴有利于促进系统正向演化。本研究基于创新生态视角进一步丰富了军民融合创新理论,为地方政府深化军民协同体制机制改革、推动军民融合深度发展提供了参考借鉴。
Abstract
Regional military-civilian S&T collaborative innovation is the key point and breakthrough to implement the military-civilian integration development strategy and innovation-driven development strategy at the regional level, and is also an important measure to improve the overall efficiency of the national innovation system and drive regional innovation development. However, there are still problems in the current regional military civilian technology collaborative innovation, such as diverse innovation entities and their interest demands, unclear cost sharing and benefit distribution mechanisms. The innovation management paradigm from the traditional perspective has been unable to meet the practical needs of regional military-civilian S&T collaborative innovation development, and it is urgent to introduce an innovation ecological perspective to solve the obstacles of regional military-civilian S&T collaborative innovation. Compared with previous innovation system theories, the innovation ecosystem theory uses stronger biological metaphors to carry out dynamic evolution analysis of the mechanism of action among various innovation agents, providing a more suitable analytical framework for solving the above problems. Therefore, introducing the theory of innovation ecosystem into the research of regional military-civilian S&T collaborative innovation and promoting the transition and evolution of the research paradigm of regional military-civilian S&T collaborative innovation from the conventional "innovation system" to "innovation ecosystem" is helpful to more deeply reveal the complex interaction between the main innovative subjects, elements and environment of military-civilian S&T collaborative innovation. Regional collaborative innovation ecosystem of military and civilian S&T is a complex network system of interaction, symbiosis, competition and dynamic evolution formed to realize the continuous emergence of military and civilian S&T innovation and integrate regional superior resources. In addition to the common characteristics of innovation ecosystem such as systematicness, symbiosis, diversity, dynamics and self-organization, it also has the unique characteristics of limited openness, cooperative target diversification, coexistence of state-led and market regulation. The formation and evolution of the regional military-civilian S&T collaborative innovation ecosystem is a process that gradually breaks the constraints of time and space, from low-level innovation to high-level innovation, from the inefficient construction stage to the advanced maturity stage. The dynamics of system evolution come from the interaction and feedback loop between the innovation population, the innovation population and the external innovation environment. In the process of evolution, the innovative populations in the system maintain a symbiotic relationship of competition and cooperation. In other words, under the action of internal and external driving forces, repeated games will be played within and between innovative populations, and the game results will ultimately affect the evolution direction of the system. Based on above research, this paper introduced the perspective of innovation ecosystem into the study of military-civilian S&T collaborative innovation, and analyzed the characteristics and evolution mechanism of regional military-civilian S&T collaborative innovation ecosystem. An evolutionary game model with military enterprise, private enterprise and local government as the key innovation subjects was constructed. Taking Heilongjiang Province as an example, the effects of benefit distribution, cost sharing and policy subsidies on the behavior of key innovation entities and system evolution were analyzed with numerical simulation. The results showed that: (1) In the case of reasonable cost sharing, even if the local government does not intervene in the military-civilian collaborative innovation, military and private enterprises will still choose to continue to cooperate in the collaborative innovation of S&T. The cost sharing coefficient has no significant influence on the strategy evolution direction of local governments. With the evolution and development of the system, local governments will eventually choose not to intervene in military-civilian collaborative innovation. (2) The fair distribution of benefits is conducive to promoting continued collaboration between military and private enterprises. In the case of unbalanced benefit distribution, the party with less benefit tends to choose the exit strategy, and the system evolution tends to disintegrate. When the distribution of benefits is extremely unbalanced, the government tends to take intervention strategies to maintain the stability of the system. (3) Whether or not local governments provide financial subsidies and how strong or weak the subsidies are will not have a fundamental impact on the evolution direction of the collaborative strategy between military and private enterprises. The sensitivity of private enterprises to financial subsidies is stronger than that of military enterprises, and appropriate financial subsidies are conducive to promoting the positive evolution of the system.
关键词
军民融合 /
军民科技协同创新 /
区域创新生态系统 /
演化博弈
Key words
military-civilian integration /
military-civilian S&T collaborative innovation /
regional innovation ecosystem /
evolutionary game
{{custom_sec.title}}
{{custom_sec.title}}
{{custom_sec.content}}
参考文献
[1] PCAST. Sustaining the nations innovation ecosystem,information technology manufacturing and competitiveness[R].2004.
[2] 王路昊, 赵帅. 区域军民融合创新体系中的边界渗透[J]. 北京理工大学学报(社会科学版), 2020,22(6): 107-114.
[3] 李毛毛, 谭劲, 王轶, 等. 国家军民融合创新示范区建设有关问题研究[J]. 中国军转民, 2017(01): 23-25.
[4] 国防大学国防经济研究中心. 中国军民融合年度发展概况[J]. 中国军转民, 2016(3): 9-14.
[5] 管玉婷. 面向军民融合的创新生态系统形成与共生演化机理研究[D]. 合肥工业大学工商管理, 2019.
[6] Brennan A, Dooley L. Networked creativity:a structured management framework for stimulating innovation[J]. Technovation, 2005,12(25): 1388-1399.
[7] 田庆锋, 张添, 张硕, 等. 军民科技协同创新要素融合机制研究[J]. 科技进步与对策, 2020,37(10): 136-145.
[8] LAZARIC N, MéRINDOL, VALéRIE, et al. Changes in the french defence innovation system:new roles and capabilities for the government agency for defence[J]. Industry & Innovation, 2011,5(18): 509-530.
[9] 余维新, 熊文明. 关键核心技术军民融合协同创新机理及协同机制研究——基于创新链视角[J]. 技术经济与管理研究, 2020,293(12): 34-39.
[10] Guttieri K R. Governance,innovation,and information and communications technology for civil-military interactions[J]. Stability International Journal Of Security&Development, 2014,1(3): 6.
[11] 曹霞, 杨笑君, 张路蓬. 技术融合壁垒视角下我国军民技术融合模式及演化分析[J]. 管理评论, 2021,33(3): 96-106.
[12] 陈印政. 创新文化与区域创新生态系统研究[J]. 技术与管理创新, 2020,5(41): 539.
[13] Estrin J. Closing the innovation gap:Reigniting the spark of creativity in a global economy[M]. New York:McGraw-Hill, 2009.
[14] Butler J, Gibson D. Research universities in the frame-work of regional innovation ecosystem:The case of Aus-tin,Texas[J]. Foresight and STI Governance, 2013(2): 42-57.
[15] Iansiti M, Levien R. Strategy as ecology[J]. Harvard Business Review, 2004,3(82): 132-133.
[16] Kapoor R, Agarwal S. Sustaining superior performance in business ecosystems:Evidence from application software developers in the iOS and Android smartphone ecosystems[J]. Organization Science, 2017(28): 531-551.
[17] 黄鲁成. 区域技术创新生态系统的特征[J]. 中国科技论坛, 2003(01): 23-26.
[18] Gawer A, Cusumano M A. Industry platforms and ecosystem innovation[J]. Journal of Product Innovation.Management, 2014,3(31): 417-433.
[19] 武翠, 谭清美. 长三角一体化区域创新生态系统动态演化研究——基于创新种群异质性与共生性视角[J]. 科技进步与对策, 2021,38(5): 38-47.
[20] 曹路苹, 李峰, 滕响林, 等. 区域军民科技协同创新生态系统的构成及优化对策研究[J]. 军民两用技术与产品, 2020(8): 9-15.
[21] 张小燕. 我国区域创新生态系统共生性研究[D]. 哈尔滨工程大学, 2020.
[22] 周雪亮, 张纪海, 韩志弘. 创新链驱动的科技园区军民科技协同创新发展模式研究[J]. 科技进步与对策, 2021,38(6): 105-112.
[23] 刘雪芹, 张贵. 创新生态系统:创新驱动的本质探源与范式转换[J]. 科技进步与对策, 2016,33(20): 1-6.
[24] 张芳, 蔡建峰. 基于政府支持的军民合作技术创新演化博弈研究[J]. 运筹与管理, 2021,30(02): 8-15.
[25] 吴洁, 车晓静, 盛永祥, 等. 基于三方演化博弈的政产学研协同创新机制研究[J]. 中国管理科学, 2019,27(01): 162-173.
[26] 卢艳秋, 廖爱红. 基于三方演化博弈的新创科技型企业集群网络嵌入机制研究[J]. 中国管理科学, 2022,2276-286(30).
[27] 方炜, 王婵, 李正锋. 演化博弈视角下军民融合协同创新合作稳定性分析[J]. 运筹与管理, 2019,28(9): 15-26.
基金
国家社会科学基金重点项目:“数字经济背景下技术创业企业商业模式创新驱动机制与实现路径研究”(20AGL009,2020.09—2023.06);黑龙江省自然科学基金项目:“区域军民科技协同创新生态系统演化机制及对策研究:以黑龙江省为例”(LH2019G004,2019.07—2022.07);中央高校基本科研业务费项目:“数字经济时代中国企业商业模式创新研究”(3072022WK0901, 2022.01 —2023.12)。