机器代工对我国制造业跨区域转移的影响研究

叶堂林 王雪莹 梁新若

科研管理 ›› 2023, Vol. 44 ›› Issue (9) : 91-98.

PDF(398 KB)
PDF(398 KB)
科研管理 ›› 2023, Vol. 44 ›› Issue (9) : 91-98.
论文

机器代工对我国制造业跨区域转移的影响研究

  • 叶堂林1,王雪莹1,2,梁新若3,4
作者信息 +

Research on the influence of industrial obots on the trans-regional transfer of manufacturing industry in China

  • Ye Tanglin1, Wang Xueying1,2, Liang Xinruo3,4
Author information +
文章历史 +

摘要

本文从产业转出地的“推力”“拉力”和产业移入地的“引力”相互作用的视角探讨了制造业转移的动因,认为机器代工作为一种典型的产业转出地“拉力”会减缓甚至抑制我国制造业的跨区域转移。运用2008—2019年中国海关进出口数据及省级面板数据,构建了回归模型进行实证检验。研究发现:(1)机器代工改变了制造业部门对生产要素的需求结构和各区域生产要素的匹配效率,缓解了我国制造业发展面临的成本压力,提升了行业竞争优势,增强了产业转出地“拉力”,表现为地区专门化率的提升,进而抑制制造业的跨区域转移。(2)当劳动力价格达到一定水平后,机器代工使得制造业部门生产要素组合的投入产出高于起初要素组合的投入产出比,有效地增强了产业转出地“黏性”,抑制了制造业的跨区域转移。

Abstract

   The paper analyzes the motivations of industrial transfer from such three forces as the "attractive force" of the place where the industry moves into, the "propulsive force" and "pulling force" of the place where the industry moves out, and it is believed that industrial robots are a typical inward "pulling force" of the place where the industry moves out, which will affect the cross-regional transfer of manufacturing. Based on this, some research hypotheses have been put forward in this paper. In order to verify the rationality of the hypothesis, on the one hand this paper draws on the measurement method of industrial space transfer by Qin Chenglin and Xiong Xueru (2013), by calculating the location quotient index of the automobile manufacturing industry in 30 provincial-level regions in China from 2008 to 2019, and performing differential processing, we can analyze whether there is a slowdown in the trend of cross-regional transfer in the automobile manufacturing industry. The analysis shows that most of the provincial-level regions in China that have promoted industrial robots on a large scale, their automobile manufacturing industry has undergone a more obvious transition from transfer-out to transfer-in after 2012.On the other hand, this paper uses China′s provincial panel data and China′s customs import and export data from 2008 to 2019 to construct a panel regression model in order to analyze the impact of industrial robots on the "stickiness" of the regional manufacturing industry and its spatial transfer. And from the perspective of labor prices, it further explored whether there is a threshold value for the specialization rate of the manufacturing area affected by industrial robots. The research draws the following conclusions: (1) Industrial robots has changed the demand structure of production factors in the manufacturing sector and the matching efficiency of production factors in various regions, alleviating the cost pressure faced by the development of China′s manufacturing industry, and by enhancing the transfer of industries. The "pulling force" is manifested in the increase in the specialization rate of manufacturing regions, which inhibits the cross-regional transfer of manufacturing. (2) When the labor price reaches a certain level, industrial robots can effectively enhance the "stickiness" of the industrial transfer area, thereby inhibiting the cross-regional transfer of manufacturing. Based on the above analysis, this paper believes that promoting the large-scale popularization and application of industrial robots will help China′s manufacturing industry to achieve " labor-saving" and "intelligence" automatic upgrades, and alleviate the development dilemma caused by the gradual disappearance of labor cost advantages, and maintain a dominant position in the "lower competition". In addition, industrial robots have weakened the importance of labor dividends to the spatial layout of the manufacturing industry. The trend of manufacturing to "automation and intelligence" will lead to the large-scale deployment of industrial robots in the manufacturing industry in the future, and the use cost of industrial robots will become an important direction for the manufacturing industry to obtain new comparative advantages.Further analysis believes that clean energy such as hydropower, photovoltaics, and wind power in the central and western regions of China is extremely abundant, and has a cost advantage in the application and promotion of industrial robots. Coupled with the decline in transportation costs brought about by the continuous improvement of transportation infrastructure, the manufacturing industry that is more dependent on industrial robots in the future has the potential to transfer to the western region. Although the eastern region will also embed industrial robots in the manufacturing industry, its motivation is to strengthen its own resistance to the impact of uncertain factors, obviously different from that of the central and western regions. Therefore, the promotion of the large-scale application of industrial robots in the eastern region should aim at "intelligent" production, promote the deep integration and upgrading of the manufacturing process, improve product quality, seize market opportunities, and promote the overall upgrade of the manufacturing value chain.

关键词

机器人替代效应 / 区位商 / 转出地“拉力” / 产业转移

Key words

substitution effect of industrial robots / location quotient / "pulling force" of the place where the industry moves out / industrial transfer

引用本文

导出引用
叶堂林 王雪莹 梁新若. 机器代工对我国制造业跨区域转移的影响研究[J]. 科研管理. 2023, 44(9): 91-98
Ye Tanglin, Wang Xueying, Liang Xinruo. Research on the influence of industrial obots on the trans-regional transfer of manufacturing industry in China[J]. Science Research Management. 2023, 44(9): 91-98

参考文献

[1]Graetz G,Michaels G.Robots at work[J].Review of Economics and Statistics,2018,100(5):753-768.
[2]李丫丫,潘安,彭永涛,杨文斌.工业机器人对省域制造业生产率的异质性影响[J].中国科技论坛,2018(06):121-126.
[3]Li B,Hou B,Yu W Lu X,Yang C.Applications of Artificial Intelligence in Intelligent Manufacturing:A Review [J].Frontiers of Information Technology&Electronic Engineering,2017,18(01):86-96.
[4]陈刚,刘珊珊.产业转移理论研究:现状与展望[J].当代财经,2006(10):91-96.
[5]魏后凯. 产业转移的发展趋势及其对竞争力的影响[J]. 福建论坛(经济社会版),2003,(4).
[6]陈建军.中国现阶段的产业区域转移及其动力机制[J].中国工业经济,2002(08):37-44.
[7]阿瑟·刘易斯(美).国际经济秩序的演变[M].北京:商务印书馆,1984.
[8]Ashcroft B,Taylor J.The Movement of Manufacturing Industry and the Effect of Regional Policy[J].Oxford Economic Papers,1977,29(1):84-101.
[9]Hanson G H.North American Integration and Industry Location[J].Oxford Review of Economic Policy,1998,14(2):30-44.
[10]J.H.Thompson.Some Theoretical consideration for manufacturing Geography,Economic Geography,1966,vol,3:127-145.
[11]Dumais,Ellison and Glaeser.Geographic concentration as a dynamic process,NBER working paper,1997,No.6270.
[12]张少军,刘志彪.全球价值链模式的产业转移——动力、影响与对中国产业升级和区域协调发展的启示[J].中国工业经济,2009(11):5-15.
[13]潘伟志.产业转移内涵、机制探析[J].生产力研究,2004(10):119-120+13.
[14]张公嵬,梁琦.产业转移与资源的空间配置效应研究[J].产业经济评论,2010,(3):1-21.
[15]牛青山.我国承接国际产业转移的现状与对策[J].山西大学学报:哲学社会科学版,2011,34(4):135-139.
[16]范剑勇.市场一体化、地区专业化与产业集聚趋势——兼谈对地区差距的影响[J].中国社会科学,2004(06):39-51+204-205.
[17]黄钟仪.产业转移:东部的趋势及西部的选择——以重庆为例[J].经济问题,2009(07):117-120.
[18]关爱萍,曹亚南.中国制造业产业转移变动趋势:2001—2014年[J].经济与管理,2016,30(06):66-72.
[19]孔凡斌,许正松,胡俊.经济增长、承接产业转移与环境污染的关系研究——基于江西省1989年~2012年统计数据的实证[J].经济经纬,2017,34(02):25-30.
[20]Maria Savona et al.Cainelli G,Evangelista R,Savona M.The Impact of Innovation on Economic Performance in Services[J].Service Industries Journal, 2004,24(1):116-130.
[21]Fuchs V R.The Determinants of the Redistribution of Manufacturing in the United States Since 1929.The Review of Economics and Statistics,1962,02.
[22]Garrett M A Jr.Growth in Manufacturing in the South,1947-1958:A Study in Regional Industrial Development.Southern Economic Journal,1968,03.
[23]Hanham R Q;Banasick S.Shift-Share Analysis and Changes in Japanese Manufacturing Employment.Growth and Change,2000.
[24]Norton R D;Rees J.The Product Cycle and the Spatial Decentralization of American Manufacturing.Regional Studies,2007.
[25]黄顺魁,王裕瑾,张可云.中国制造业八大区域转移分析——基于偏离—份额分析[J].经济地理,2013,33(12):90-96.
[26]刘红光,刘卫东,刘志高.区域间产业转移定量测度研究——基于区域间投入产出表分析[J].中国工业经济,2011,(6):79-88.
[27]吕洁,杜传文,李元旭.工业机器人应用会倒逼一国制造业劳动力结构转型吗?——基于1990—2015年间22个国家的经验分析[J].科技管理研究,2017,37(22):32-41.
[28]韩民春,韩青江,冯钟.工业机器人技术进步对就业的影响分析:一个理论模型框架[J].广东财经大学学报,2019,34(06):4-10.
[29]马岚.中国会出现机器人对人工的规模替代吗?——基于日韩经验的实证研究[J].世界经济研究,2015(10):71-79+128-129.
[30]杜传文,李晴,芮明杰,吕洁.大规模工业机器人应用与异质性技能劳动力之间的替代互补关系[J].中国科技论坛,2018(08):174-182.
[31]韩民春,赵一帆.工业机器人对中国制造业的就业效应[J].工业技术经济,2019,38(11):3-12.
[32]张于喆.人工智能、机器人的就业效应及对策建议[J].科学管理研究,2019,37(01):43-45+109.
[33]张桂金,张东.“机器换人”对工人工资影响的异质性效应:基于中国的经验[J].学术论坛,2019,42(05):18-25.
[34]余玲铮,魏下海,吴春秀.机器人对劳动收入份额的影响研究——来自企业调查的微观证据[J].中国人口科学,2019(04):114-125+128.
[35]杨晓锋.智能制造是否有助于提升制造业平均工资?——基于2001~2016年17省工业机器人数据研究[J].经济体制改革,2018(06):169-176.
[36]王兵,王启超.全要素生产率、资源错配与工业智能化战略——基于广东企业的分析[J].广东社会科学,2019(05):17-26.
[37]李丫丫,潘安.工业机器人进口对中国制造业生产率提升的机理及实证研究[J].世界经济研究,2017(03):87-96+136.
[38]宋旭光,左马华青.工业机器人投入、劳动力供给与劳动生产率[J].改革,2019(09):45-54.
[39]De Backer K,De Stefano T,Menon C,Suh J R.Industrial Robotics and the Global Organisation of Production[R].OECD Science,Technology and Industry Working Paper,2018.
[40]Caggiano A,Teti R. Digital Factory Technologies for Robotic Automation and Enhanced Manufacturing Cell Design[J].Cogent Engineering,2018,5(01):1426676.
[41]刘胜,陈秀英.“机器换人”能否成为全球价值链攀升新动力?[J].经济体制改革,2019(05):179-186.
[42]覃成林,熊雪如.我国制造业产业转移动态演变及特征分析——基于相对净流量指标的测度[J].产业经济研究,2013(01):12-21.
[43]许怡,许辉.“机器换人”的两种模式及其社会影响[J].文化纵横,2019(03):88-96+143.
[44]王业强,魏后凯.产业特征、空间竞争与制造业地理集中——来自中国的经验证据[J].管理世界,2007(04):68-77+171-172.
[45]Cantos P,Gumbau-Albert M,Maudos J.Transport infrastructures,spillover effects and regional growth:Evidence of the Spanish case[J]. Transport Reviews,2005,25(1):25?50
[46]刘明,王霞,中国制造业空间转移趋势及其影响因素:2007~2017[J].数量经济技术经济研究,2020,37(03):26-46.
[47]陈刚,陈红儿.区际产业转移理论探微[J].贵州社会科学,2001,(4).
[48]董桂才.中国工业机器人出口贸易及其影响因素研究[J].国际经贸探索,2015,31(11):30-40.
[49]程虹,陈文津,李唐.机器人在中国:现状、未来与影响——来自中国企业-劳动力匹配调查(CEES)的经验证据[J].宏观质量研究,2018,6(03):1-21.

基金

“市属高校分类发展——京津冀协同发展与城市群系统演化的政产学研用平台构建”资助;北京市自然科学基金面上项目:“京津冀创新驱动发展战略的实施路径研究——基于社会资本、区域创新及创新效率的视角”(9212002);国家自然科学基金青年基金项目:“‘回音室’效应视角下的社会化媒体虚假信息传播机理与干预策略研究”(72004143)。

PDF(398 KB)

Accesses

Citation

Detail

段落导航
相关文章

/