关键核心技术研究综述：概念、结构、突破路径与机制

李显君; 冯堃; 熊昱; 傅渝; 姚毓春

doi:10.19571/j.cnki.1000-2995.2023.12.003

PDF(1486 KB)

科研管理 ›› 2023, Vol. 44 ›› Issue (12) : 21-30. DOI: 10.19571/j.cnki.1000-2995.2023.12.003

论文

关键核心技术研究综述：概念、结构、突破路径与机制

冯堃²，李显君¹，熊昱¹，傅渝¹，姚毓春²

作者信息 +

A review of key core technologies: Concept, structure, breakthrough path and mechanism

Feng Kun², Li Xianjun¹, Xiong Yu¹, Fu Yu¹, Yao Yuchun²

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

突破关键核心技术“卡脖子”束缚成为我国打破美国科技封锁和实现国家崛起的理论和实践战略问题。本文从概念、内在结构、突破路径与机制对关键核心技术研究进行了系统梳理和总结，发现主流创新理论与技术追赶理论均未对关键核心技术进行专门研究，国内创新领域对此研究尚处于起步阶段，尚存在五个研究缺口：一是关键核心技术及相关概念混乱，对本源问题研究十分不足；二是底层逻辑的研究十分匮乏，尤其对关键核心技术微观结构及演化机理的研究更为匮乏，尚未打开关键核心技术黑箱；三是鲜有对关键核心技术的研发路径与机制研究；四是宏观突破路径及机制研究有待丰富和深化，尤其缺乏多情境下关键核心技术突破机制研究；五是研究文献没有脱离主流创新理论范式。最后，基于现有研究不足缺口，本文提出了未来研究展望与框架，即建立基于中国情境下的关键核心技术突破理论。

Abstract

Breaking through the bottleneck of key core technology has become a theory and strategic research topic for China to break the US scientific and technology blockade and realize the national rise. This paper systematically combed and summarized the key core technology research from the concept, internal structure, breakthrough path and mechanism. We find that neither the mainstream innovation theory nor technological catch-up theory for latecomer countries have literature focusing on key core technology, and the innovation research on this topic is still at an early stage in China. Therefore, there are five research gaps of key core technology, confusion of key core technologies and related concepts, lacking research on the origin problems, the unopened box of key core technologies, lacking discussion on the underlying logic of the microstructure and evolution mechanism of key core technologies, little research on the R&D path and mechanism of key core technology, limited research on macro breakthrough path and mechanism, lacking study on breakthrough mechanism of key core technology under multiple scenarios, deep influence of the mainstream innovation theory paradigm on the existing research literature. Finally, based on the gaps in existing research, this paper proposes a prospect and framework for future research, establishing key core technology breakthrough theories based on Chinese context.

导出引用

冯堃李显君熊昱傅渝姚毓春. 关键核心技术研究综述：概念、结构、突破路径与机制[J]. 科研管理. 2023, 44(12): 21-30 https://doi.org/10.19571/j.cnki.1000-2995.2023.12.003

Feng Kun, Li Xianjun, Xiong Yu, Fu Yu, Yao Yuchun. A review of key core technologies: Concept, structure, breakthrough path and mechanism[J]. Science Research Management. 2023, 44(12): 21-30 https://doi.org/10.19571/j.cnki.1000-2995.2023.12.003

参考文献

[1] 陈劲. 产业关键核心技术“卡脖子”问题的突破路径[J].中国经济评论，2021, (2):64-67.
CHEN Jin. Breakthrough path for the “neck-jamming” of key core technologies in the industry[J]. China Economic Review, 2021, (2):64-67.
[2] 柳卸林,常馨之,董彩婷. 构建创新生态系统，实现核心技术突破性创新——以IMEC在集成电路领域创新实践为例[J].科学学与科学技术管理, 2021, 42(9):3-18.
LIU Xielin, CHANG Xinzhi , Dong Caiting. Build an ecosystem, realize breakthrough innovation in core technology fields: Take IMEC's practice in the semiconductor field as an example[J]. Science of Science and Management of S.& T., 2021, 42(09): 3-18.
[3] 谭劲松,宋娟,王可欣等. 创新生态系统视角下核心企业突破关键核心技术“卡脖子”——以中国高速列车牵引系统为例[J/OL].南开管理评论, 2022: 1-28. [2023-06-01]. http://kns.cnki.net/kcms/detail/12.1288.f.20220311.1333.002.html.
TAN Jinsong, SONG Juan, WANG Kexin, et al. Breakthrough of key core technology “Neck-Jamming” by focal firm from innovation ecosystem perspect—A case study of Chinese high-speed train traction system[J/OL]. Nankai Business Review, 2022: 1-28. [2023-06-01]. http://kns.cnki.net/kcms/detail/12.1288.f.20220311.1333.002.html.
[4] 余江,陈凤,张越,刘瑞. 铸造强国重器:关键核心技术突破的规律探索与体系构建[J].中国科学院院刊, 2019, 34(3):339-343.
YU Jiang, CHEN Feng, ZHANG Yue, et al. Forging pillars of scientific and technological power: Mechanism exploration and system construction for breakthrough of core and key technologies[J]. Bulletin of Chinese Academy of Sciences, 2019, 34(3):339-343.
[5] 张树满,原长弘. 制造业领军企业如何培育关键核心技术持续创新能力?[J]科研管理, 2022, 43(4):103-110.
ZHANG Shuman, YUAN Changhong. How do leading manufacturers cultivate the continuous innovation capacities in key core technologies? [J]. Science Research Management, 2022, 43(4): 103-110.
[6] 杨思莹.政府推动关键核心技术创新:理论基础与实践方案[J].经济学家, 2020, (9):85-94.
YANG Siying. The government promotes key core technological innovation: Theoretical basis and practical solutions[J]. Economist, 2020, (9):85-94.
[7] 中国社会科学院工业经济研究所课题组. 产业链链长的理论内涵及其功能实现[J].中国工业经济, 2022， (7):5-24.
RESEARCH GROUP OF THE INSTITUTE OF INDUSTRIAL ECONOMICS OF CASS. The theoretical connotation of the central enterprise as the chain leader of industry chain and the function realization[J]. China Industrial Economics, 2022, (7):5-24.
[8] BELL M, PAVITT K. Technological accumulation and industrial growth: contrasts between developed and developing countries[J]. Industrial and Corporate Change, 1993, 2(1): 157-157.
[9] FRISHAMMAR, J., H. FLORéN, J. WINCENT. Beyond managing uncertainty: Insights from studying equivocality in the fuzzy front end of product and process innovation projects[J]. IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management, 2011, 29: 468–88.
[10] 李显君. 汽车理想国[M].北京：工人出版社. 2017.
LI Xianjun. Automotive utopia[M]. Beijing: China Workers Press, 2017.
[11] 李显君,孟东晖,刘暐. 核心技术微观机理与突破路径——以中国汽车AMT技术为例[J].中国软科学, 2018, (08):88-104.
LI Xianjun, MENG Donghui, LIU Wei. Micro mechanism and breakthrough path of core technology: Evidence from China’s automotive AMT technology[J]. China Soft Science, 2018, (08):88-104.
[12] 孟东晖. 中国汽车产业核心技术突破路径与机制研究[D].清华大学博士论文. 2019.
MENG Donghui. Research on the path and mechanisms of Chinese automotive industry’s core technology breakthrough[D]. Beijing: Tsinghua University. 2019
[13] HOBDAY, M.，RUSH, H., BESSANT, J. Approaching the innovation frontier in Korea: The transition phase to leadership[J]. Research Policy, 2004, 33(10): 1433-1457.
[14] LEE，K.， MALERBA，F. Catch-up cycles and changes in industrial leadership: Windows of opportunity and responses of firms and countries in the evolution of sectoral systems[J]. Research Policy, 2017, 46(2): 338-351.
[15] WHANG, Y., HOBDAY, M. Local ‘test bed’ market demand in the transition to leadership: The case of the Korean mobile handset industry[J]. World Development, 2011, 39(8): 1358-1371.
[16] 吴晓波,付亚男,吴东等. 后发企业如何从追赶到超越?——基于机会窗口视角的双案例纵向对比分析[J].管理世界, 2019, 35(02):151-167+200.
WU Xiaobo, FU Yanan, WU Dong, et al. How do latecomers transform from catch-up to beyond catch-up? A longitudinal comparative analysis of two cases based on window of opportunity perspective[J]. Journal of Management World, 2019, 35(02):151-167+200.
[17] 路风,何鹏宇. 举国体制与重大突破——以特殊机构执行和完成重大任务的历史经验及启示[J].管理世界, 2021, 37(7):1-18+1.
LU Feng, HE Pengju. The new-type system of nationwide mobilization and breakthroughs: Historical experiences of accomplishing major tasks by special agencies and the lessons[J]. Journal of Management World, 2021, 37(7):1-18+1.
[18] 葛爽,柳卸林. 我国关键核心技术组织方式与研发模式分析—基于创新生态系统的思考[J].科学学研究, 2022, 40(11):2093-2101.
GE Shuang, LIU Xielin. Study on the organization and R&D mode of China’s key technology-Based on the perspective of innovation ecosystem[J]. Studies in Science of Science, 2022, 40(11):2093-2101.
[19] 王瑞琪,原长弘. 制造业领军企业关键核心技术突破因素——基于8家中国制造业500强企业的多案例研究[J].科技管理研究, 2022, 14:85-93.
WANG Ruiqi, YUAN Changhong. An analysis of key successful factors affecting the breakthrough of major core technology of China leading manufacturing companies—multiple case studies of eight China leading manufacturing companies[J]. Science and Technology Management Research, 2022, 14:85-93.
[20] WACKER, J. G. A definition of theory: research guidelines for different theory-building research methods in operations management[J]. Journal of Operations Management, 1998, 16: 361-385.
[21] 余博. 企业自主创新存在五大陷阱[J].经济纵横, 2006, (05):59-62.
YU Bo. Five major pitfalls in independent innovation of enterprises[J]. Economic Review, 2006, (05):59-62.
[22] 张治河,苗欣苑. “卡脖子”关键核心技术的甄选机制研究[J].陕西师范大学学报:哲学社会科学版, 2020, 49(6):5-15.
ZHANG Zhihe, MIAO Xinyuan. Research on the selection mechanism of the key and core technology[J]. Journal of Shaanxi Normal University(Philosophy and Social Science Edition), 2020, 49(6):5-15.
[23] 陈劲, 阳镇, 朱子钦. “十四五”时期“卡脖子”技术的破解:识别框架、战略转向与突破路径[J].改革, 2020, (12):5-15.
CHEN Jin, YANG Zhen, ZHU Ziqin. The solution of “Neck sticking” technology during the 14th five-year plan period: Identification framework, strategic change and breakthrough path[J]. Reform, 2020, (12):5-15.
[24] 宋立丰,区钰贤,王静,刘箭章. 基于重大科技工程的“卡脖子”技术突破机制研究[J].科学学研究, 2022, 40(11):1191-2000.
SONG Lifeng, QU Yuxian, WANG Jing, et al. Research on the breakthrough mechanism of "stuck neck" technology based on STE mega projects under the background of the new national system——Case Study on BeiDou Navigation Satellite System[J]. Studies in Science of Science, 2022, 40(11):1191-2000.
[25] QUINE, W. V., J. S. ULLIAN. The Web of Belief, Second ed[M]. New York: McGrawHill, Inc. 1980.
[26] 太原重型机器厂设计科. 3000吨汽车纵梁液压机及其关键技术试验总结[J].重型机械，1977, 10（6）:46-55.
DESIGN SECTION OF TAIYUAN HEAVY MACHINERY FACTORY. Test summary of 3000 ton automobile longitudinal hydraulic press and key technology[J]. Heavy Machinery, 1977, 10（6）:46-55.
[27] 丁元煦. 从日本工业发展看技术引进必须与科研相结合[J].科研管理, 1980, (1):59-67.
DING Yuanxu. Technology introduction must be combined with scientific research from the perspective of Japan's industrial development[J]. Science Research Management, 1980, (1):59-67.
[28] 全裕吉,陈益云. 从非核心技术创新到核心技术创新:中小企业创新的一种战略[J].科学管理研究, 2003, 21(3):5-8+27.
QUAN Yuji, CHEN Yiyun. From normal-technology innovation to core-technology innovation: a Technological-innovating strategy of the small and medium-sized enterprises[J]. Scientific Management Research, 2003, 21(3):5-8+27.
[29] 孙涛涛,金碧辉. 关键技术挖掘与企业技术竞争情报———以 DVD 激光头技术为例[J].图书情报工作, 2008, (5):129-132.
SUN Taotao, JIN Bihui. Key Technologies Mining and CTI in Enterprises ——Taking the Case of DVD Optical Pickup Technology as an Example[J]. Library and Information Service, 2008, (5):129-132.
[30] 郑思佳,汪雪锋,刘玉琴等. 关键核心技术竞争态势评估研究[J].科研管理, 2021, 42(10):1-10.
ZHENG Sijia, WANG Xuefeng, LIU Yuqin, et al. A research on evaluation of the competitive situation of key core technologies[J]. Science Research Management, 2021, 42(10):1-10.
[31] 王续琨,刘洋,侯剑华. 论战略性新兴技术[J].科学学研究, 2011, 29(11):1601-1606.
WANG Xukun, LIU Yang, HOU Jianhua. Discourse upon strategic emerging technologies[J]. Studies in Science of Science, 2011, 29(11):1601-1606.
[32] 胡旭博,原长弘. 关键核心技术:概念、特征与突破因素[J].科学学研究, 2022, 40(1):4-11.
HU Xubo, YUAN Changhong. Key part of core technology: Concept, characters and breakthrough factors[J]. Studies in Science of Science, 2022, 40(1):4-11.
[33] 苏敬勤,刘静. 复杂产品系统创新的核心技术控制力演化——验证性多案例研究[J].科学学与科学技术管理, 2014, 35(9):24-31.
SU Jingqin, LIU Jing. Deconstruction and dynamic evolution of core technology control: Based on complex products and systems innovation[J]. Science of Science and Management of S. & T., 2014, 35(9):24-31.
[34] TAYLOR A, HELFAT C E. Organizational linkages for surviving technological change: Complementary assets, middle management, and ambidexterity[J]. Organization Science, 2009, 20(4): 718-739.
[35] 吴贵生,王毅. 技术创新管理[M].北京:清华大学出版社. 2009.
WU Guisheng, WANG Yi. Management of Technological Innovation[M]. Tsinghua University Press. 2009.
[36] 张玉臣,谭礼. 关键核心技术的概念界定、特征辨析及突破路径[J].中国科技论坛, 2023, 322(02):20-29.
ZHANG Yuchen, TAN Li. Concept definition, characteristic discrimination and breakthrough path of key core technology[J]. Forum on Science and Technology in China, 2023, 322(02):20-29.
[37] 谭劲松,宋娟,陈晓红. 产业创新生态系统的形成与演进:“架构者”变迁及其战略行为演变[J].管理世界, 2021, (9):167-192.
TAN Jinsong, SONG Juan, CHEN Xiaohong. The formation and evolution of industrial innovation ecosystem: "Architect" transition and the evolution of its strategic behavior[J]. Journal of Management World,2021, (9):167-192.
[38] 辜胜阻,吴华君,吴沁沁,等. 创新驱动与核心技术突破是高质量发展的基石[J].中国软科学,2018, (10):9-18.
GU Shengzu, WU Huajun, WU Qinqin, et al. Innovation-driven and core technology breakthrough: The cornerstone of high-quality development[J]. China Soft Science, 2018, (10):9-18.
[39] 李红勋. 基于国家安全视角构建关键核心技术管理体系[J].科学管理研究, 2015, 33(02):12-15.
LI Hongxun. Based on the national security perspective to build key core technology management system[J]. Scientific Management Research, 2015, 33(02):12-15.
[40] 王璐瑶,曲冠楠,Juan Rogers. 面向“卡脖子”问题的知识创新生态系统分析：核心挑战、理论构建与现实路径[J].科研管理, 2022, 43(04):94-102.
WANG Luyao, QU Guannan, JUAN ROGERS. An analysis of the knowledge innovation ecosystem to handle the "stranglehold" challenges: The core challenges，theory construction and realization path[J]. Science Research Management, 2022, 43(04):94-102.
[41] 汤志伟,李昱璇,张龙鹏. 中美贸易摩擦背景下“卡脖子”技术识别方法与突破路径——以电子信息产业为例[J].科技进步与对策, 2021, 38(01):1-9.
TANG Zhiwei, LI Yuxuan, ZHANG Longpeng. Identification method and breakthrough path of “neck-jamming” technologies under the background of Sino-US trade friction: a Case of the electronic information industry[J]. Science & Technology Progress and Policy, 2021, 38(01):1-9.
[42] 原长弘,张树满.以企业为主体的产学研协同创新:管理框架构建[J].科研管理, 2019, 40(10):184-192.
YUAN Changhong, ZHANG Shuman. IUR collaborative innovation with the enterprise as the mainstay: The construction of a management framework[J]. Science Research Management, 2019, 40(10):184-192.
[43] 王敏,银路. 突破关键核心技术“卡脖子”困境的路径研究[J].清华经管评论, 2022, (5):45-50.
WANG Min, YIN Lu. Research on breakthrough path for "neck-jamming" dilemma of key core technologies[J]. Tsinghua Business Review, 2022, (5):45-50.
[44] LAUDAN, R. Cognitive change in technology and science[M]. In Rachel Laudan, ed., The nature of Knowledge: are models of scientific change relevant? Dordrecht: Kluwer. 1984.
[45] MOKYR J. The Gifts of Athena: Historical Origins of the Knowledge Economy[M]. Princeton University Press. 2004.
[46] AGHION, P., C. ANTONIN, S. BUNEL. The power of creative destruction[M]. London: Belknap Press: An Imprint of Harvard University Press. 2021.
[47] 李显君,熊昱,冯堃. 中国高铁产业核心技术突破路径与机制[J].科研管理, 2020, 41(10):1-10.
LI Xianjun, XIONG Yu, FENG Kun. Core technology breakthrough path and mechanism of China's high － speed rail industry[J]. Science Research Management, 2020, 41(10):1-10.
[48] 汪贤文. 我国制造业关键核心技术突破路径研究[D].中南财经政法大学硕士论文. 2021.
WANG Xianwen. A study on the breakthrough path of key-core technologies in China’s manufacturing industry[D]. Wuhan, Hubei: Zhongnan University of Economics and Law. 2021.
[49] 张羽飞,原长弘. 产学研深度融合突破关键核心技术的演进研究[J].科学学研究, 2022, 40(05):852-862.
ZHANG Yufei, YUAN Changhong. Study on the evolution mechanism of breaking through key core technologies through industry-university-research deep integration[J]. Studies in Science of Science, 2022, 40(05):852-862.
[50] 郑刚,邓宛如,王颂等. 企业创新网络构建、演化与关键核心技术突破[J].科研管理, 2022, 43(07):85-95.
ZHENG Gang, DENG Wanru, WANG Song, et al. Construction and evolution of enterprise innovation network and breakthrough of key core technologies[J]. Science Research Management, 2022, 43(07):85-95.
[51] ARTHUR, W. B. The Nature of Technology[M]. London: Penguin Books. 2009.
[52] 胡登峰,黄紫微,冯楠等. 关键核心技术突破与国产替代路径及机制——科大讯飞智能语音技术纵向案例研究[J].管理世界, 2022, 38(05):188-209.
HU Dengfeng, HUANG Ziwei, FENG Nan, et al. Path and mechanism of core technology breakthrough and domestic substitution: A longitudinal case study of IFLY TEK intelligent speech technology[J]. Journal of Management World，2022, 38(05):188-209.
[53] 宋艳, 原长弘, 张树满. 装备制造业领军企业如何突破关键核心技术?[J].科学学研究, 2022, 40(3):420-432.
SONG Yan, YUAN Changhong, ZHANG Shuman. How to break through key core technologies for leading equipment manufacturing companies[J]. Studies in Science of Science, 2022, 40(3):420-432.
[54] 柳卸林,高雨辰,丁雪辰. 寻找创新驱动发展的新理论思维:基于新熊彼特增长理论的思考[J].管理世界, 2017, 32(12):8-19.
LIU Xielin, GAO Yuchen, DING Xuechen. Searching new theoretical thinking of innovation-driven development——a New Schumpeterian growth theory[J]. Journal of Management World, 2017, 32(12):8-19.
[55] 陈劲,阳镇,朱子钦. 新型举国体制的理论逻辑、落地模式与应用场景[J]. 改革, 2021, (5):1-17.
CHEN Jin, YANG Zhen, ZHU Ziqin. The theoretical logic, implementation mode and application scenario of the new type of national system[J]. Reform, 2021, (5):1-17.
[56] 包云岗. 关键核心技术的发展规律探析[J].中国科学院院刊, 2022, 37(5):636-641.
BAO Yungang. Analysis of principles of development of key technologies[J]. Bulletin of Chinese Academy of Sciences, 2022, 37(5):636-641.
[57] KAPOOR R. Ecosystems: broadening the locus of value creation[J]. Journal of Organization Design, 2018, 7(1):13-24.
[58] VON HIPPEL E. Lead users: A source of novel product concepts[J]. Management Science, 1986, 32(7): 791-805.
[59] HOBDAY M. East latecomer firms: Learning the technology of electronics[J]. Word Development, 1995, 23(7): 1171-1193.
[60] 彭新敏,马帅. 国际领先客户、国内产学研与后发企业追赶[J].科学学研究, 2023, 41(04):659-668.
PENG Xinmin, MA Shuai. The international leading customers, domestic university-industry collaboration and catch-up of latecomer firms[J]. Studies in Science of Science, 2023, 41(04):659-668.
[61] 赵晶,刘玉洁,付珂语,张勇,李欣. 大型国企发挥产业链链长职能的路径与机制——基于特高压输电工程的案例研究[J].管理世界, 2022, 38(05):221-240.
ZHAO Jin, LIU Yujie, FU Keyu, et al. The path and mechanism for large state-owned enterprises to play the function of industry chain leader: A case study based on UHV transmission project[J]. Journal of Management World, 2022, 38(05):221-240.
[62] 李政. 国有企业推进高水平科技自立自强的作用与机制路径[J].科学学与科学技术管理, 2023, 44(01):55-67.
LI Zheng. State-owned enterprises in promoting sci-tech self-reliance and self-strengthening at higher levels: The role, mechanism and trajectory[J]. Science of Science and Management of S.& T., 2023, 44(01):55-67.
[63] 李慧敏,陈光. 日本“技术立国”战略下自主技术创新的经验与启示——基于国家创新系统研究视角[J].科学学与科学技术管理, 2022, 43(02):3-18.
LI Huimin, CHEN Guang. Considering “nation based on technology” under the perspective of national innovation system: Japan’s experience and enlightenment in tackling key and core technologies[J]. Science of Science and Management of S.& T., 2022, 43(02):3-18.
[64] 余江,管开轩,李哲,陈凤. 聚焦关键核心技术攻关强化国家科技创新体系化能力[J].中国科学院院刊, 2020, 35(8):1018-1023.
YU Jiang, GUAN Kaixuan, LI Zhe, et al. Focus on Key Technology Breakthroughs, and Strengthen National Scientific and Technological Innovation Systematization Capability[J]. Bulletin of Chinese Academy of Sciences, 2020, 35(8):1018-1023.
[65] LUNDVALL, B., C. RIKAP. China’s catching-up in artificial intelligence seen as a co-evolution of corporate and national innovation systems[J]. Research Policy, 2022, 51: 104395.
[66] MENG, D., X. LI, K. RONG. Industry-to-university knowledge transfer in ecosystem-based academic entrepreneurship: Case study of automotive dynamics & control group in Tsinghua University[J]. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 2019, 141: 249-262.
[67] 欧阳桃花,曾德麟. 拨云见日—揭示中国盾构机技术赶超的艰辛与辉煌[J].管理世界, 2021, 37(8):194-207.
OUYANG Taohua, ZENG Delin. Dispel the clouds and see the sun: Reveal the hardship and glory of China’s shield machine technology catch-up[J]. Journal of Management World, 2021, 37(8):194-207.
[68] 范旭,刘伟. 中国光纤产业关键核心技术自主可控实现之路[J].科学学研究, 2022, 40(10):1767-1777.
FAN Wei, LIU Wei. The road of independent and controllable realization of key core technologies in China＇s optical fiber industry[J]. Studies in Science of Science, 2022, 40(10):1767-1777.
[69] 李维维,于贵芳,温珂. 关键核心技术攻关中的政府角色:学习型创新网络形成与发展的动态视角: 美、日半导体产业研发联盟的比较案例分析及对我国的启示[J].中国软科学, 2021, (12):50-60.
LI Weiwei, YU Guifang, WEN Ke. Role of government in the key technology breakthroughs: a Dynamic perspective on the formation and development of learning innovation network ———a Comparative case study between VLSI and SEMATECH and the implications to China[J]. China Soft Science, 2021, (12):50-60.
[70] 张三保, 陈晨, 张志学. 举国体制演进如何推动关键技术升级? —中国3G到5G标准的案例研究[J].经济管理, 2022, 9:27-46.
ZHANG Sanbao, CHEN Chen, ZHANG Zhixue. How Does the Evolution of the Nationwide System the Upgrading of Key Technologies? Cases of China from 3G to 5G[J]. Business and Management Journal, 2022, 9:27-46.
[71] MOORE, J. F. Predators and Prey: A New Ecology of Competition[J]. Harvard Business Review, 1993, 71(3): 75-86.