主导逻辑：内涵、研究议题及未来展望

张璐; 韩玉琪; 严子淳; 崔敏杰; 长青

PDF(652 KB)

科研管理 ›› 2022, Vol. 43 ›› Issue (4) : 165-176.

论文

主导逻辑：内涵、研究议题及未来展望

张璐¹，韩玉琪¹，严子淳²，崔敏杰^1,3，张强¹，吴玉杰⁴

作者信息 +

The dominant logic: Connotations, research topics and future prospects

Zhang Lu¹, Han Yuqi¹, Yan Zichun², Cui Minjie^1,3, Zhang Qiang¹, Wu Yujie⁴

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

主导逻辑作为企业内部主导的一般管理逻辑，是指导企业制定相关战略决策、采取行动以快速响应外部动态复杂的市场环境的先导模块，对组织的战略决策、战略部署及战略执行具有指导作用而备受学界关注。本文以1986-2020年间与研究主题相关的211篇中外文文献为研究对象，在可视化分析的基础上归纳并整理现有研究成果，总结出主导逻辑的发展进程、概念内涵、形成机制、特性及类型划分等内容，并从与主导逻辑相关的企业竞争优势、价值创造及服务创新等热点议题对已有研究进行系统梳理，构建了主导逻辑理论知识框架。本文较为系统全面的梳理了主导逻辑理论现有研究，同时期望能够引起我国学者的关注，进一步探寻组织内部多元主导逻辑共存的内在机制，完善相关理论体系；补充服务主导逻辑对消费者影响的相关研究，丰富多类型主导逻辑的认知及作用机理；期望学界产出更多以具有我国国情特色的管理实践现象为研究土壤的高质量研究，从而为实践界在动态复杂的外部环境中构建主导逻辑提升组织竞争能力提供丰富的理论借鉴。

Abstract

Dominant logic theory, as a methodology to guide enterprises to construct organizational cognition and generate action practices to shape competitive advantages, has attracted academic attention. At present, the research of dominant logic is mainly about the combination of service-oriented logic, innovation management, marketing and so on, the evolution from commodity dominant logic to service dominant logic, and the interpretation of the relationship between service-oriented dominant logic and value co-creation. Although this provides a rich theoretical basis for Chinese scholars to carry out relevant research, the existing research lacks the basic knowledge of the dominant logic theory from the perspective of the whole process of theoretical development, fails to systematically sort out its theoretical development context and hot issues, and lacks common theoretical basis to build knowledge framework. As a result, it is difficult for the academic circle to summarize and explore the local extension application of the dominant logic theory based on the existing literature, and the practice circle cannot accurately refine the core management ideas to guide the enterprise innovation practice based on the existing research. Therefore, it′s very necessary for the dominant logic theory literature systematically comb, further clarify the basic knowledge of content, and the research category of overall development, is advantageous for the related academics dominate the logical theory knowledge architecture and hotspot issues and development process to carry out academic research and boosting development and perfection of the dominant logic theory system.
Based on WOS database and CNKI database, this paper conducts retrieval in both Chinese and English to obtain sample data, adopts the research method combining bibliometrics and induction, systematically combs sample literature from the perspective of the whole process of theoretical development, and clarifies the development context and research hotspots of the dominant logic theory.
In order to systematically understand the research status of dominant logic, this paper firstly conducts descriptive statistics on the sample literature, discovers that: the research on dominant logic in China started late, but its annual publication fluctuation trajectory is generally similar to that of international research; the research hotspots of dominant logic involve the research directions represented by high-frequency keywords such as service-dominant logic, co-creation, management, performance, innovation and strategy; the research on dominant logic has evolved from exploring "the internal relationship between enterprise multiple strategies and performance", to "responding to market demand to improve service capacity", and then to "attaching importance to create value with consumers to gain competitive advantage".
Secondly, this paper clarifies the origin of dominant logic and finds that this concept has been applied from psychology and philosophy to the field of strategic management. It refers to a potential rule of internal operation of an organization. At the same time, this paper gives a clear definition of the concept of dominant logic. In addition, this paper differentiates the concept of dominant logic from similar concepts such as manager cognition, organization cognition and organization practice.
Finally, this paper explores the application and expansion of dominant logic theory, summarizes its formation mechanism, action mechanism and characteristics, and then constructs the knowledge framework. On this basis, this paper puts forward the future development direction, guides scholars to enrich the localization research of shared cognition of senior management team and the coexistence operation mechanism of multi dominant logic within enterprises, and further deepen the internal mechanism of dominant logic, in order to provide theoretical reference for Chinese scholars to deepen the theoretical research of dominant logic from the theoretical level, from the practical level, it provides a reference for enriching the management experience of enterprise executives in making strategic decisions and changing the internal dominant logic.

导出引用

张璐, 韩玉琪, 严子淳, 崔敏杰, 张强, 吴玉杰. 主导逻辑：内涵、研究议题及未来展望[J]. 科研管理. 2022, 43(4): 165-176

Zhang Lu, Han Yuqi, Yan Zichun, Cui Minjie, Zhang Qiang, Wu Yujie. The dominant logic: Connotations, research topics and future prospects[J]. Science Research Management. 2022, 43(4): 165-176

参考文献

[1] 张璐,梁丽娜,苏敬勤,张强,长青. 破茧成蝶：创业企业如何突破能力的刚性束缚实现进阶？[J]. 管理世界, 2020,36(06):189-201+253.
Zhang Lu，Liang Lina，Su Jingqin，Zhang Qiang，Chang Qing．Breaking cocoon into a butterfly: How entrepreneurial enterprises breakthrough the rigid constraints of the ability to achieve progress? [J]. Journal of Management World, 2020,36(06):189-201+253.
[2] 苏敬勤,单国栋. 本土企业的主导逻辑初探:博弈式差异化——基于装备制造业的探索性案例研究[J]. 管理评论, 2017,29(02):255-272.
Su Jingqin, Shan Guodong. Dominant logic of local firms: differentiation in difference order——An exploratory case study based on the EMI[J]. Journal of Management Review, 2017,29(02):255-272.
[3] 张璐,闫红月,苏敬勤,文宗川,张强. 从“锁定”到“进阶”：如何突破主导逻辑的路径依赖——基于战略认知视角的案例研究[J]. 南开管理评论, 2021,24(01):86-96+117-118.
Zhang Lu, Yan Hongyue, Su Jingqing, Wen Zongchuan, Zhang Qiang. From "locking" to "progression": How to break through the path dependence of dominant logic? A case study based on the perspective of strategic cognition[J]. Journal of Nankai Business Review, 2021,24(01):86-96+117-118.
[4] 张平,梁淑茵,王利伟. 高管变更、政治关联与被并购企业绩效——基于美的集团三次并购的研究[J]. 管理案例研究与评论, 2014,7(05):392-406.
Zhang Ping, Liang Shuyin, Wang Liwei. Top management turnover, connection and performance of acquired enterprise: Research based on three acquisitions of Midea group[J]. Journal of Management Case Studies, 2014,7(05):392-406.
[5] 刘朔,蓝海林,柯南楠. 转型期后发企业核心能力构建研究——格力电器朱江洪的管理之道[J]. 管理学报, 2019,16(09):1265-1278.
Liu Shuo, Lan Hailin, Ke Nannan. Research on the construction of core competence of Chinese Later Comer Firms during the transitional period——Management thoughts of entrepreneur ZHU Jianghong of GREE Electric Appliances, Inc[J]. Chinese Journal of Management, 2019,16(09):1265-1278.
[6] Bettis, Prahalad; Richard A. The Dominant Logic: A New Linkage between Diversity and Performance[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 1986,7(6):485-501.
[7] Lusch, Robert F. Nambisan, Satish. Service innovation: A service-dominant logic perspective[J]. 2015,39(01):155-175.
[8] 简兆权,秦睿. 服务主导逻辑：核心概念与基本原理[J]. 研究与发展管理, 2021,33(02):166-181.
Jian Zhaoquan, Qin Rui. Service-Dominant Logic: Core Concepts and Fundamentals[J]. Journal of R&D Management, 2021,33(02):166-181.
[9] Ainhize, Eletxigerra, Jose, et al. Place marketing examined through a service-dominant logic lens: A review[J]. Journal of Destination Marketing & Management, 2018(9):72-84.
[10] 刘林青,雷昊,谭力文. 从商品主导逻辑到服务主导逻辑——以苹果公司为例[J]. 中国工业经济, 2010(09):57-66.
Liu Linqing, Lei Hao, Tan Liwen. From commodity dominant logic to service dominant logic——A case of Apple Co. Ltd. [J]. China Industrial Economics, 2010(09):57-66.
[11] Grant R M . On 'dominant logic', relatedness and the link between diversity and performance[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 1988, 9(6):639-642.
[12] Vargo S L , Lusch R F . Evolving to a New Dominant Logic for Marketing[J]. Journal of Marketing, 2004, 68(1):1-17.
[13] Prahalad R . The dominant logic: Retrospective and extension[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 2010, 16(1):5-14.
[14] 吴瑶,肖静华,谢康,廖雪华. 从价值提供到价值共创的营销转型——企业与消费者协同演化视角的双案例研究[J]. 管理世界, 2017(04):138-157.
Wu Yao, Xiao Jinghua, Xie Kang, Liao Xuehua. Marketing transformation from value provision to value co creation——A double case study from the perspective of collaborative evolution between enterprises and consumers[J]. Journal of Management World, 2017(04):138-157.
[15] Gellatly, A. Cognition and culture: A cross-cultural approach to cognitive psychology[J]. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology Section A: Human Experimental Psychology, 1996,49(1): 265-266.
[16] Cole M , Scribner S . Culture & thought: A psychological introduction[J]. British journal of educational psychology, 1975, 45(2):91-91.
[17] Posner M I . Foundations of Cognitive Science[J]. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience, 1989, 2(4):387-94.
[18] Spiegel-Roesing I , D . de Solla Price, et al. Science, technology and society; a cross-disciplinary perspective[J]. American Journal of Physics, 1980, 48(4):323-323.
[19] Kuhn Thomas. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions[J]. Philosophical Books, 1962, 4(3):14-16.
[20] Prahalad C K , Bettis R A . Diversity and Performance: The Elusive Linkage[J]. SMU Digital Repository, 1983,1(1):1-40.
[21] Krogh G V , Roos J . A Tale of the Unfinished[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 2015, 17(9):729-737.
[22] Kor Y Y , Mesko A . Dynamic managerial capabilities: Configuration and orchestration of top executives' capabilities and the firm's dominant logic[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 2013, 34(2):233-244.
[23] Prahalad C K . The Blinders of Dominant Logic[J]. Long Range Planning, 2004, 37(2):171-179.
[24] Tomasz Obloj, Krzysztof Obloj, Michael G. Pratt. Dominant Logic and Entrepreneurial Firms' Performance in a Transition Economy[J]. Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice,2010,34(1):151-170.
[25] Slater, Stanley F., John C. Narver, Market Orientation and the Learning Organization[J]. Journal of Marketing, 1995, 59(7), 63–74.
[26] Prahalad C K., Ramaswamy V. Co-opting customer competence[J]. Harvard Business Review, 2000,78（1/2）：79-87.
[27] Lusch R.F. Vargo S.L. Competing through service: Insights from service-dominant logic[J]. Journal of Retailing, 2007,1(83):5-18.
[28] Dixon, D . F. Marketing as production: The development of a concept[J]. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 1990, 18(4):337-343.
[29] Stephen L. Vargo，Robert F. Lusch. Institutions and axioms: an extension and update of service-dominant logic[J]. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 2015, 44(1):5-23.
[30] Vargo SL，Lusch R F．From repeat patronage to value co-creation in service ecosystems: A transcending conceptualization of relationship[J]. Journal of Business Market Management, 2010,4(4):169-179．
[31] Arnould E J . Service-dominant logic and resource theory[J]. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 2008,36(1):21-24.
[32] Quinn J B . Strategic change: Logical incrementalism[J]. Sloan management review, 1980, 20(1):7-21.
[33] Giovanni Gavetti, Daniel Levinthal. Looking Forward and Looking Backward: Cognitive and Experiential Search[J]. Administrative Science Quarterly, 2000, 45(1):113-137.
[34] 苏敬勤,单国栋. 复杂产品系统企业的主导逻辑—以大连机车为例[J]. 科研管理, 2016,37(06):92-102.
Su Jingqin, Shan Guodong. The dominant logic of complex products and systems manufacturers based on a case study of CNR Dalian [J]. Science Research Management, 2016,37(06):92-102.
[35] Beesley L . Organizational Learning[J]. Annual Review of Sociology, 1988,14(14):319-340.
[36] B.A. Walters, Priem R L , Shook C L . Small business manager scanning emphases and the dominant logic of the business-level strategy[J]. Journal of Small Business Strategy, 2005, 15(2):19-32.
[37] Malin Br?nnback, Patricia Wiklund. A new dominant logic and its implications for knowledge management: a study of the Finnish food industry[J]. Knowledge & Process Management, 2001, 8(4):197–206.
[38] Nancy, J, Adler. International dimensions of organizational behavior[J]. Thunderbird International Business Review, 1986, 28(1):31-32.
[39] 邱国栋,董姝妍. 从组织记忆到组织遗忘:基于“抛弃政策”的战略变革研究——以长春一汽发展历程为案例[J]. 中国软科学, 2016(09):168-179.
Qiu Guodong, Dong Shuyan. From organizational memory to organizational forgetting: Research on strategic change based on abandonment: A single-case of FAW's development history[J]. China Soft Science, 2016(09):168-179.
[40] Garud R , Kumaraswamy A , Karnoee P . Path Dependence or Path Creation?[J]. Journal of Management Studies, 2010, 47(4): 760- 774.
[41] Canas J J , Antoli A , Fajardo I , et al. Cognitive inflexibility and the development and use of strategies for solving complex dynamic problems: effects of different types of training[J]. Theoretical Issues in Ergonomics Science, 2005, 6(1):95-108.
[42] 张璐,曲廷琛,张强,苏敬勤,长昊东. 主导逻辑类型的形成及演化路径——基于蒙草生态的案例研究[J].科学学与科学技术管理, 2019,40(03):56-69.
Zhang Lu, QU Tingchen, Zhang Qiang, Su Jingqin, Chang Haodong. The formation and evolution path of dominant logic types: A case study based on the M-Grass Ecology Corporation [J].Science of Science and Management of S.&.T, 2019,40(03):56-69.
[43] Barr P S , Stimpert J L , Huff A S . Cognitive change, strategic action, and organizational renewal[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 2010, 13(S1):15-36.
[44] Holan P M D , Phillips N . Remembrance of Things Past? The Dynamics of Organizational Forgetting[J]. Management ence, 2004, 50(11):1603-1613.
[45] Maijanen P . Cognition as a driver and barrier of strategic renewal: Case of the Finnish Broadcasting Company[J]. International Journal of Business Innovation & Research, 2015, 9(3):351-388.
[46] Schraven D , Hartmann A , Dewulf G . Resuming an Unfinished Tale: Applying Causal Maps to Analyze the Dominant Logics Within an Organization[J]. Organizational Research Methods, 2015, 18(2):326-349.
[47] Greenwood R , Raynard M , Kodeih F , et al. Institutional Complexity and Organizational Responses[J]. Academy of Management Annals, 2011, 5(1):317-371.
[48] Engelmann, Alexander Kump, Barbara Schweiger, Christina. Clarifying the Dominant Logic Construct by Disentangling and Reassembling its Dimensions[J]. International Journal of Management Reviews, 2020,4(22)：323-355.
[49] Nadkarni, S., & Barr, P.S. Environmental context, managerial cognition, and strategic action: An integrated view[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 2008, 29(13), 1395-1427.
[50] Nadkarni S , Narayanan V K . Strategic schemas, strategic flexibility, and firm performance: the moderating role of industry clockspeed[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 2007, 28(3):243-270.
[51] Mcnamara, G.M., Luce, R.A., Tompson, G. H. Examining the effect of complexity in strategic group knowledge structures on firm performance[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 2002, 23(2), 153-170.
[52]王毅.以核心能力为主导逻辑的战略管理[J]. 科研管理, 2001(03): 13-19.
[53] Eltantawy R A , Giunipero L . An empirical examination of strategic sourcing dominant logic: Strategic sourcing centricity[J]. Journal of Purchasing & Supply Management, 2013, 19(4):215-226.
[54] 江积海. 商业模式是“新瓶装旧酒”吗?——学术争议、主导逻辑及理论基础[J]. 研究与发展管理, 2015,27(02):12-24.
Jiang Jihai. Is business model “old wine in a new bottle”? ——Academic debates，dominant logic，and theoretical grounding [J]. Journal of R&D Management, 2015,27(02):12-24.
[55] 黄旭,李一鸣,张梦. 不确定环境下企业战略变革主导逻辑新范式[J]. 中国工业经济, 2004(11):60-67.
Huang Xu, Li Yiming, Zhang Meng. Framework of dominant logic analysis for business strategic transformation under uncertainty environment[J]. China Industrial Economics, 2004(11):60-67.
[56] Kowalkowski, Christian. Dynamics of value propositions: Insights from service-dominant logic[J]. European Journal of Marketing, 2015, 45(1/2):277-294.
[57] Krogh G V , Erat P , Macus M . Exploring the Link between Dominant Logic and Company Performance[J]. Creativity & Innovation Management, 2002, 9(2):82-93.
[58] Lampel J , Shamsie J . Research notes and communications; probing the unobtrusive link: dominant logic and the design of joint ventures at general electric[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 2000, 21(5):593-602.
[59] Franke T , Knyphausen Aufsess D Z . On dominant logic: review and synthesis[J]. Journal of Business Economics, 2014, 84(1):27-70.
[60] Teece D J , Shuen P A . Dynamic capabilities and strategic management[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 1997, 18(7):509-533.
[61] Vargo S L , Lusch R F . Service-dominant logic: continuing the evolution[J]. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 2008, 36(1):1-10.
[62] Madhavaram S , Hunt S D . The service-dominant logic and a hierarchy of operant resources: developing masterful operant resources and implications for marketing strategy[J]. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 2008, 36(1):67-82.
[63] Vargo S L . Toward a transcending conceptualization of relationship: a service-dominant logic perspective[J]. Journal of business & industrial marketing, 2009, 24(5-6):373-379.
[64] Brodie R J , Hollebeek L D , Juric B , et al. Customer engagement: conceptual domain, fundamental propositions, and implications for research[J]. Journal of Service Research, 2011, 17(3):1-20.
[65] Payne A F , Storbacka K , Frow P . Managing the co-creation of value[J]. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 2008, 36(1):83-96.
[66] Gr?nroos, C. Adopting a service logic for marketing[J]. Marketing Theory, 2006, 6(3):317-333.
[67] Baker, William E. and James M. Sinkula, Does Market Orientation Facilitate Balanced Innovation Programs? An Organizational Learning Perspective[J]. Journal of Product Innovation Management, 2007, 24 (4), 316-334.
[68] Kallenberg R, Oliva R. Managing the transition from product to services[J]. International Journal of Service Industry Management, 2003,14(2):160-172.
[69] Ordanini A , Parasuraman A . Service Innovation Viewed Through a Service-Dominant Logic Lens: A Conceptual Framework and Empirical Analysis[J]. Journal of Service Research, 2015, 14(1):3-23.
[70] Lusch R F , Vargo S L , Tanniru M . Service, value networks and learning[J]. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 2010, 38(1):19-31.
[71] Romero D , Molina A . Collaborative Networked Organisations and Customer Communities: Value Co-Creation and Co-Innovation in the Networking Era[J]. Production Planning and Control, 2011, 22(5-6):447-472.
[72] Lee, Yu-Lung Pan, Lee-Yun Hsu, Chin-Hsien ,et al. Exploring the Sustainability Correlation of Value Co-Creation and Customer Loyalty-A Case Study of Fitness Clubs[J]. Sustainability, 2018, 11(1):1-15.
[73] Alok K R , Srivastava M . The Antecedents of Customer Loyalty: An Empirical Investigation in Life Insurance Context[J]. Journal of Competitiveness, 2013, 5(2):139-163.