试论创新系统的客观性

肖新军; 张治河; 易兰

PDF(3036 KB)

科研管理 ›› 2021, Vol. 42 ›› Issue (2) : 64-76.

论文

试论创新系统的客观性

肖新军,张治河,易兰

作者信息 +

A tentative study on the objectivity of innovation system

Xiao Xinjun, Zhang Zhihe, Yi Lan

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

创新系统理论是西方学者针对发达国家完善的市场经济体制提出的。在计划经济体制下是否同样存在创新系统呢？在深入理解创新系统理论内核的基础上，本文对1949年以来中国在计划经济体制和市场经济体制两种体制下创新系统发展的理论和实践进行了系统梳理和研究，并从“两弹一星”的研制成功、GDP总量持续攀升、全球竞争力指数持续攀升、全球创新指数持续攀升和世界500强企业总数持续攀升等方面阐明了不同时期我国创新系统的存在以及在相应创新系统作用下中国创新与发展取得的重大成果。主要研究结果表明，无论是计划经济体制还是市场经济体制，创新系统都是客观存在的，且不以创新主体的意志为转移。主导一个国家经济超常规发展的关键原因，不是创新系统由哪类创新主体主导的问题，而是不论何种经济体制下，国家都需要努力建立与本国发展阶段、创新要素和制度环境相匹配、相适应、相协调的创新系统。不论创新系统如何演进，国家在其中都扮演着不可替代的角色。

Abstract

The theory of innovation system is put forward by western scholars aiming at the mature market economy system in developed countries. Did the innovation system also exist under the planned economy system?Although the systematic research of innovation system in China began in the middle and late 1990s, the practical exploration of China′s innovation system was initiated as early as the early 1950s. Under the planned economy system, China marshalled the full resources of the country to tackle the key problems in science and technology after the completion of the three major transformations, taking the opportunity of the implementation of the medium and long-term science and technology development plan as well as the five-year plan. As a result, the "two bombs and one satellite" project was successfully developed which brought a hard-earned peaceful environment for China′s economic growth. In 1971, China′s GDP ranked among the top 16 in the world. Before the reform and opening up, China basically achieved the goal of "establishing an independent and relatively sound industrial system and national economic system". Historical facts have proved that innovation system did exist in China under the traditional planned economy system.

After China′s reform and opening up in 1978, the Chinese economy started to compete and cooperate with the world economy in an all-round and multi-level way. In 1995, China explicitly proposed “two transformations”: First, the transformation of its economic system from a traditional planned economy to a socialist market economy; Second, the transformation of the mode of economic growth from extensive to intensive. Since then, China′s economic development has entered the fast lane of rapid growth. China′s GDP surpassed Japan′s in 2010 to become the world′s second largest, and reached US $90 trillion in 2018. The ranking of China′s international competitiveness rose from 44th in 2000 to 28th in 2019, and its global innovation index jumped from 29th in 2011 to 14th in 2019. Furthermore, in 2019, the total number of "World Top 500" enterprises in China reached 129, surpassing the United States for the first time and becoming the country with the largest number of large enterprises in the world. All these facts fully prove that under the socialist market system, the innovation system in this period greatly boosted the rapid growth of China′s economy. All in all, the existence of China′s innovation system in different periods and the innovation and development of China under the corresponding innovation system have made great achievements.In this paper, the theory and practice of innovation system under the planned economy system and the market economy system in China since 1949 has been systematically sorted out and studied.

Based on an in-depth understanding of the core of innovation system theory. The main results show that the innovation system exists objectively and does not depend on the will of the innovation entity in either the planned economy system or the market economy system. The key reason leading a country to achieve extraordinary economic development is not decided by the type of innovation entity dominating the innovation system, but that no matter what kind of economic system, the country should establish an innovation system that matches, adapts to and coordinates with its own development stage, innovation elements and institutional environment. No matter how the innovation system evolves，the country plays an irreplaceable role in it.

导出引用

肖新军张治河易兰. 试论创新系统的客观性[J]. 科研管理. 2021, 42(2): 64-76

Xiao Xinjun, Zhang Zhihe, Yi Lan. A tentative study on the objectivity of innovation system[J]. Science Research Management. 2021, 42(2): 64-76

参考文献

[1] Lundvall B.-Å. Product innovation and user-producer interaction[M].Aalborg:Aalborg University Press，1985.

[2] Freeman C. Technology policy and economic performance：Lessons from Japan[M]. London：Pinter，1987.

[3] Lundvall B.-Å. National systems of innovation：Towards a theory of innovation and interactive learning[M]. London：Pinter，1992.

[4] Richard R. National innovation systems：A comparative analysis[M]. Oxford :Oxford University Press，1993.

[5] Edquist C. Systems of innovation：Technologies，institutions and organization[M]. London：Pinter Publisher，1997．

[6] OECD．National Innovation Systems[R].Paris：OECD，1997：09-12．

[7] Freeman C. Continental，national and sub-national innovation systems—Complementarity and economic growth[J]. Research Policy，2002，31(2)：191-211．

[8] 魏江，陶颜，胡胜蓉. 创新系统多层次架构研究[J].自然辩证法通讯，2007(4)：37-43+80+112．

Wei Jiang, Tao Yan, Hu Shengrong. Research on multi-level architecture of innovation systems[J].Journal of Dialectics of Nature, 2007(4)：37-43+80+112．

[9] [挪]詹·法格博格；[美]戴维·莫利；[美]理查德·纳尔逊主编；柳卸林，郑刚，蔺雷，李纪珍译. 牛津创新手册[M].北京：知识产权出版社，2009.6:01-05.

Fagerberg Jan, Mowery David C, Nelson Richard R. Liu Xielin, Zheng Gang, Lin Lei, Li Jizhen(translate).The Oxford Handbook of Innovation[M]. Beijing：Intellectual Property Publishing House Co., Ltd. 2009.6：01-05.

[10] 张治河，周国华，胡锐，谢忠泉. 创新学：一个驱动21世纪发展的新兴学科[J].科研管理，2011，32(12)：143-150.

Zhang Zhihe, Zhou Guohua, Hu Rui, Xie Zhongquan. Innovation studies：An emerging discipline driving economic development and improving social welfare in the 21st century[J].Science Research Management, 2011，32(12)：143-150.

[11] 代明，殷仪金，戴谢尔. 创新理论：1912-2012——纪念熊彼特《经济发展理论》首版100周年[J].经济学动态，2012(4)：145-152.

Dai Ming, Yin Yijin, Dai Xieer. Innovation theory：1912-2012 -- in Memory of the 100th Anniversary of the First Edition of Schumpeter's the theory of economic development [J].Economic Perspectives, 2012(4)：145-152.

[12] [美]熊彼特著；何畏等译﹒经济发展理论——对于利润、资本、信贷、利息和经济周期的考察[M].北京：商务印书馆，1990.05:75-76.

Schumpeter A. Joseph. He Wei, et.al (translate).The theory of economic development- A study of profit, capital, credit, interest and business cycle[M]. Beijing：The Commercial Press，1990.05：75-76.

[13] 范家骧，高天虹. 熊彼特经济理论体系(下) [J].经济纵横，1988(7)：61-63.

Fan Jiaxiang, Gao Tianhong. Schumpeter's economic theory system (Part 2) [J].Economic Review Journal, 1988(7)：61-63.

[14] 齐建国,等. 技术创新——国家系统的改革与重组[M].北京：社会科学文献出版社， 1995.12：5-7.

Qi Jianguo, et.al. Technological innovation：Reform and reorganization of national system[M]. Beijing：Social Sciences Academic Press(China), 1995.12：5-7.

[15] [德]弗里德里希·李斯特（Friedrich List）著；陈万煦译. 政治经济学的国民体系[M].北京：商务印书馆，1961.11.

List Friedrich. Chen Wanxu(translate).The national system of political economy[M]. Beijing：The Commercial Press, 1961. 11.

[16] [美]布朗温·H.霍尔（Bronwyn H.Hall），[美]内森·罗森伯格（Nathan Rosenberg）. 创新经济学手册第2卷[M].上海：上海交通大学出版社，2017.06：457-478.

Hall. H. Bronwyn, Rosenberg Nathan. Handbook of the Economics of Innovation (Part2)[M]. Shanghai：Shanghai Jiao Tong University Press, 2017.06：457-478.

[17] Lundvall B.-Å. National systems of innovation：Toward a theory of innovation and interactive learning[J]. Research Policy，1995，24(4)：318-30.

[18] Leydesdorff L，Porto-Gomez I. Measuring the expected synergy in Spanish regional and national systems of innovation[J]. The Journal of Technology Transfer，2017，49(1)：189-209.

[19] Schut M， Rodenburg J， Klerkx L，et al. RAAIS：Rapid appraisal of agricultural innovation systems (Part II).Integrated analysis of parasitic weed problems in rice in Tanzania[J] . Agricultural Systems，2015，132：12-24.

[20] Wonglimpiyarat，Jarunee. The innovation incubator，university business incubator and technology transfer strategy：The case of Thailand[J]. Technology in Society，2016：18-27.

[21] Gadelha C A G，Temporão，José Gomes，et al. Development，innovation and health：The theoretical and political perspective of the Health Economic-Industrial Complex[J].Ciencia & Saude Coletiva，2018， 23（6）：1891-1902.

[22] 孔德涌. 国家创新管理系统—一个自适应控制系统[J].科学学与科学技术管理，1990(12)：4-6.

Kong Deyong. National innovation management system -- An adaptive control system [J].Science of Science and Management of S.& T. , 1990(12)：4-6.

[23] 汤世国. 中国的国家创新体系:变革与前景[J].中国软科学，1993(1)：33-35.

Tang Shiguo. China’ national innovation system：Reform and prospect [J]. China Soft Science,1993(1)：33-35.

[24] 陈劲. 国家创新系统：对实施科技发展道路的新探索[J].自然辩证法通讯，1994(6)：22-29.

Chen Jin. National innovation system：A new exploration on the implementation of science and technology development path [J]. Journal of Dialectics of Nature, 1994(6)：22-29.

[25] 周寄中，胡志坚，周勇. 在国家创新系统内优化配置科技资源[J].管理科学学报，2002(3)：40-49.

Zhou Jizhong, Hu Zhijian, Zhou Yong. Allocating S&T resources in national systems of innovation[J]. Journal of Management Sciences in China, 2002(3)：40-49.

[26] 马松尧. 科技中介在国家创新系统中的功能及其体系构建[J].中国软科学，2004(1)：109-113+120.

Ma Songyao. A research on the functions of intermediary service of science and technology in national innovation system and the construction of the organization system[J]. China Soft Science, 2004(1)：109-113+120.

[27] 王春法. 关于国家创新体系理论的思考[J].中国软科学，2003(5)：99-104.

Wang Chunfa. Some issues on the theory of national innovation system[J]. China Soft Science, 2003(5)：99-104.

[28] 路甬祥. 创新与未来：面向知识经济时代的国家创新体系[M].北京：科学出版社，1998.05.

Lu Yongxiang. Innovation and future：The national innovation system in the era of knowledge economy[M]. Beijing：Science Press, 1998.05.

[29] 中国社会科学院研究生院，中国科学院研究生院编. 知识经济与国家创新体系[M]. 北京：经济管理出版社，1998.12.

Chinese Academy of Social Sciences Graduate School, Chinese Academy of Sciences. Knowledge economy and national innovation system[M]. Beijing:Economy and Management Publishing House,1998.12.

[30] 石定寰. 国家创新系统现状与未来[M].北京：经济管理出版社，1999.01．

Shi Dinghuan. Current situation and future of national innovation system[M].Beijing：Economy and Management Publishing House,1999.01.

[31] 冯之浚. 国家创新系统的理论与政策[M].北京：经济科学出版社，1999.03.

Feng Zhijun. Theory and policy of national innovation system[M].Beijing：Economic Science Press, 1999.03.

[32] 胡志坚. 国家创新系统——理论分析与国际比较[M].北京：社会科学文献出版社，2000.01.

Hu Zhijian. National innovation system—Theoretical analysis and international comparison[M]. Beijing：Social Sciences Academic Press(China), 2000.01.

[33] 张治河. 面向“中国光谷”的产业创新系统研究[D].武汉：武汉理工大学，2003.

Zhang Zhihe. The research of the industrial innovation system based on the OPtics

Valley of China[D]. Wuhan:Wuhan University of Technology,2003.

[34] 陈劲，吴贵生. 中国创新学派：30年回顾与未来展望[M].北京：清华大学出版社，2018.10：3-13.

Chen Jin, Wu Guisheng. Chinese innovation school:30-years review and outlook[M].Beijing:Tsinghua University Press, 2018.10：3-13.

[35] 老田. 六七十年代我国科技快速进步的奥秘[J].农村工作通讯，2005(09)：56-57.

Lao Tian. The mystery of the rapid progress of science and technology in China in the 1960s and 1970s[J]. Journal of Rural Work Communication, 2005(09)：56-57.

[36] 冯之浚，刘燕华，方新，穆荣平，张伟.创新是发展的根本动力[J].科研管理，2015，36(11)：01-10.

Feng Zhijun, Liu Yanhua, Fang Xin, Mu Rongping, Zhang Wei. Innovation is the fundamental driving force for development[J].Science Research Management, 2015，36(11)：01-10.

[37] 金碚. 关于“高质量发展”的经济学研究[J].中国工业经济，2018(04)：05-18.

Jin Bei. Study on the “High-Quality Development” Economics[J].China Industrial Economics, 2018(04)：05-18.