科研管理 ›› 2021, Vol. 42 ›› Issue (11): 118-128.

• • 上一篇    下一篇

国企混改对企业社会责任的影响研究

庄莹,买生   

  1. 石河子大学经济与管理学院,新疆 石河子832000
  • 收稿日期:2020-12-10 修回日期:2021-05-17 出版日期:2021-11-20 发布日期:2021-11-15
  • 通讯作者: 买生
  • 基金资助:
    国家自然科学基金项目:“基于行为金融与信息不对称视角的资产误定价研究”(71562029,2016.01—2019.12);新疆生产建设兵团重点领域科技攻关计划:“南疆特色农产品综合物流产业体系建设战略研究”(2017DB08,2018.09—2021.06)。 

A research on the influence of state-owned enterprises′ mixed ownership reform on their corporate social responsibility

Zhuang Ying, Mai Sheng   

  1. School of Economics and Management, Shihezi University, Shihezi 832000, Xinjiang, China
  • Received:2020-12-10 Revised:2021-05-17 Online:2021-11-20 Published:2021-11-15

摘要:      国企混合所有制改革(简称“国企混改”)是我国经济体制改革的核心,非国有资本参与对国企产生治理效应的同时,也一定程度影响政策性决策行为,那么国企“使命必然”的社会责任表现也会因此产生影响。本文从减负效应与治理效应双重视角出发探究国企混改股权结构对企业社会责任的影响。研究表明:国企混改动态股权结构变化,包括多样性、深入度、制衡度以及控制权转移均会降低企业社会责任水平。且机制检验发现,国企混改不仅可通过减负效应,即缓解国企承担的政策性义务从而对企业社会责任产生影响,还可通过治理效应监督约束管理层为获隐性福利而提升企业社会责任水平行为。此外,基于控制层级与治理环境的视角进一步研究发现,与央企相比,地方国企混改对企业社会责任水平的抑制作用更明显;市场化进程较高、政府放权意愿较强地区,治理环境较好从而能够强化国企混改对企业社会责任水平的影响。最后,研究发现国企混改降低企业社会责任水平具体表现在员工、供应链以及环境责任,并最终有效缓解企业社会责任带来的负向价值效应,提升企业价值。研究认为国企混改应注重股权结构“量变与质变”相结合,充分发挥非国有资本的治理效能,明确国企社会责任本质,促使国企提升绩效的同时,有效发挥企业社会责任的榜样作用。

关键词: 国企, 混合所有制改革, 企业社会责任

Abstract:      State-owned enterprise mixed ownership reform is the core of China economic system reform, while the participation of non-state capital has a governance effect on state-owned enterprises, it also affects policy decision-making behavior to a certain extent, then the participation of non-state capital in the mixed ownership reform of state-owned enterprises will also have an impact on the performance of state-owned enterprises′ "mission and inevitable" social responsibility. This paper explores the impact of state-owned enterprises′ mixed ownership structure on corporate social responsibility from two perspectives: burden reduction effect and governance effect. 
   The empirical research results show that: (1) Changes in the dynamic equity structure of state-owned enterprise mixed reform, including diversity, depth, checks and balances, and transfer of control rights, will reduce the level of corporate social responsibility. (2) The mechanism test found the mixed reform of state-owned enterprises can not only alleviate the policy obligations of state-owned enterprises through the burden-reducing effect, thereby having an impact on corporate social responsibility, but also effectively supervise and constrain the management′s behavior to improve the level of corporate social responsibility in order to obtain hidden benefits through the governance effect. (3) In addition, based on the perspective of control hierarchy and governance environment, further research found that compared with state-owned enterprises, the mixed reform of local state-owned enterprises has a more obvious inhibitory effect on the level of corporate social responsibility; regions with a high marketization process and strong government willingness to delegate power have a better governance environment, which can strengthen the impact of the mixed reform of state-owned enterprises on the level of corporate social responsibility. (4) Finally, this paper finds that the mixed reform of state-owned enterprises reduces the level of corporate social responsibility, which is reflected in employees, supply chain and environmental responsibility. And effectively alleviate the negative value effect brought by corporate social responsibility and enhance corporate value. Research believes that the mixed reform of state-owned enterprises should focus on the combination of "quantitative and qualitative changes" in the ownership structure, give full play to the governance efficiency of non-state capital, clarify the nature of the social responsibility of state-owned enterprises, encourage state-owned enterprises to effectively play a role model of corporate social responsibility while improving performance. 
   Our contribution is that: (1) This paper clarifies the path of influence of the mixed reform of state-owned enterprises on corporate social responsibility. (2) Clarify the role of the governance environment in the mixed reform of state-owned enterprises, the nature of state-owned enterprises′ social responsibilities, and the importance of non-state-owned capital′s participation in the ownership structure that influences the decision-making of "quantitative and qualitative changes", it provides certain theoretical and empirical evidence for clarifying the controversy over the effectiveness of the reform of state-owned enterprises and deepening the practice of mixed reform of state-owned enterprises.
  Our research also has some important management implications: (1) The mixed reform of state-owned enterprises not only needs to pay attention to the "quantitative change" of multiple equity, but also the effective "qualitative change" of the deepening, checks and balances and transfer of the shareholding formed by the participation of heterogeneous shareholders, to produce effective checks and balances. In related industries that are not related to the national economy and people′s livelihood, encourage the appropriate transfer of state-owned equity, give full play to the governance role of non-state capital, reduce the "pressure" (policy obligations) of state-owned enterprises, and squeeze out the "water" of corporate social responsibility (agency issue). (2) In the future, the practice of mixed reform should focus on the heterogeneous characteristics of enterprises at different levels of control and the characteristics of the institutional environment. It is necessary to vigorously promote the process of mixed improvement of local state-owned enterprises. (3) Relying on the introduction of non-state-owned capital can optimize the internal governance of enterprises, thereby reducing the level of corporate social responsibility and enhancing corporate value, but the social responsibility and "model role" that state-owned enterprises themselves need to bear cannot be ignored, thereby enhancing corporate value and corporate social responsibility.

Key words:  state-owned enterprise, mixed ownership reform, corporate social responsibility