科研管理 ›› 2018, Vol. 39 ›› Issue (8): 151-160.

• 论文 • 上一篇    下一篇

不同阶段信任与惩罚机制匹配的知识网络交流效率研究:基于整体网络结构的分析

吕鸿江1,吴亮1,周应堂2   

  1. 1.东南大学经济管理学院,江苏 南京210096;
    2.南京农业大学工学院,江苏 南京210031
  • 收稿日期:2015-10-29 修回日期:2017-08-05 出版日期:2018-08-20 发布日期:2018-08-21
  • 通讯作者: 吕鸿江
  • 基金资助:

    国家自然科学基金面上项目(71472036,2015.01-2018.12);江苏省社会科学基金项目(15GLB010,2016.01-2017.06);江苏高校哲学社会科学重点课题(2017ZDIXM015,2017.06-2019.12);“青蓝工程”项目(2017ZDIXM015,2016.06-201812);中央高校基本科研业务费专项资金项目(3214007413,2017.01-2017.12);南京农业大学工学院企业管理创新研究团队(gxz14007,2015.01-2018.12)。

A research on communication efficiency of the knowledge network where trust mechanism matches with punishment mechanism

Lv Hongjiang1, Wu Liang1, Zhou Yingtang2   

  1. 1. School of Economics and Management, Southeast University, Nanjing 210096, Jiangsu, China;
    2. School of Engineering, Nanjing Agriculture University, Nanjing 210031, Jiangsu, China
  • Received:2015-10-29 Revised:2017-08-05 Online:2018-08-20 Published:2018-08-21

摘要: 信任和惩罚机制影响知识网络交流效率的重要机制。目前研究大多只重视信任机制的作用或是将两类机制割裂开来讨论,无法全面反映两类机制同时存在并相互匹配对知识网络交流效率的影响。本文通过构建了两阶段八类知识交流网络的仿真模型,综合分析两种机制在知识网络交流不同阶段的互动匹配产生的知识网络交流效率。研究发现,①知识交流初期阶段,高初始信任机制和高短期惩罚机制匹配的紧密的临时任务型知识网络具有最高的短期知识交流效率,低初始信任机制和低短期惩罚机制匹配的松散的临时团队型知识网络具有最低的短期知识交流效率;高初始信任机制和高短期惩罚机制匹配的紧密的临时任务型知识网络的知识交流效率会快速增加,再逐渐持平,其他短期知识网络的知识效率则呈现先逐渐下降,然后逐渐持平的变化规律;高初始信任机制比高短期惩罚机制更有利于提高短期知识交流效率。②知识交流发展阶段,高持续信任机制和高长期惩罚机制匹配的脆弱的情感型知识网络具有最高的长期知识交流效率,低持续信任机制和低长期惩罚机制匹配的牢固的交易型知识网络具有最低的长期知识交流效率;高持续信任机制和高长期惩罚机制匹配的脆弱的情感型知识网络的知识交流效率会不断增加,其他长期知识网络的知识交流效率会逐渐降低;高长期惩罚机制比高持续信任机制更有利于提高长期知识交流效率。③知识网络整体结构特征在上述不同信任和惩罚机制匹配的知识网络交流效率中发挥了重要作用。该研究避免了以往割裂地分析信任和惩罚机制的片面性,弥补了过去缺乏对分阶段动态过程探讨的不足,从短期和长期展现了信任和惩罚机制动态匹配影响知识网络交流效率的全貌,对提高不同阶段知识网络交流效率的机制设置有重要实践启示。

关键词: 知识网络, 交流效率, 信任机制, 惩罚机制

Abstract: Trust mechanisms and punishment mechanisms were important factors affecting on the exchange efficiency of knowledge networks. Most studies discussed Trust mechanisms or mechanisms separately, can not fully reflect the matching between two types of mechanisms in knowledge exchange network. By constructing a simulation model of a two-phase eight-class knowledge-sharing network and analyzing comprehensively the two mechanisms for the knowledge exchange networks in different stages. We found, ① In the early stages of the exchange of knowledge, the short-term knowledge exchange efficiency of the temporary task-based knowledge network with high initial trust mechanism and high short-term punishment mechanism is the highest, the short-term knowledge exchange efficiency of the temporary team knowledge network with low initial trust mechanism and low short-term punishment mechanism is the lowest, the short-term knowledge exchange efficiency of the temporary task-based knowledge network rapidly increase, then gradually flat, other short-term knowledge exchange efficiency is showing first declined, then gradually flat; high initial trust mechanism is more important than high short-term punishment mechanism.②In the development stages of the exchange of knowledge, the long-term knowledge exchange efficiency of the fragile emotional knowledge network with high sustained trust mechanism and high long-term punishment mechanism was the highest, the long-term knowledge exchange efficiency of the Strong transactional knowledge network with low sustained trust mechanism and low long-term punishment mechanism was the lowest, the long-term knowledge exchange efficiency of the fragile emotional knowledge network will continue to increase, other long-term knowledge exchange efficiency will be gradually reduced; high long-term punishment mechanism is more important than high sustained trust mechanism.③ the whole knowledge network structure had played an important role in the above-mentioned different trust and punishment mechanism to match. The study avoids the conventional analysis fragmented trust and punishment mechanism of one-sidedness, to make up for the lack of discussion of past deficiencies dynamic process stages, from short-term and long-term trust and punishment mechanism to show the dynamic matching knowledge network and exchange efficiency of the whole picture, to improve Different stages of knowledge networks provided important management inspiration.

Key words:  knowledge networks, exchange efficiency, trust mechanism, punishment mechanism