作为科技论文中不可缺少的组成部分,参考文献往往是决定论文水平的重要因素之 一;而被引频次是进行论文评价的重要指标之一,两者是否存在着相关关系?针对这一问题,本文从参考文献的数量与论文被引频次的相关性分析,以及高被引文献的参考文献篇均被引频次与论文被引频次的相关性分析两个角度展开研究,探讨了参考文献的数量与质量对论文被引频次的影响.研究表明,参考文献与被引频次之间的相关性不明显,参考文献可以作为一个独立于被引频次的论文评价指标.
Abstract
As an indispensable part of scientific papers, reference tends to be one of the important factors that decide the level of papers. Meanwhile, citation is one of the important indexes for paper evaluation. Is there a correlation between the two factors? In order to solve this problem, we study from two points: the correlation between the quantity of reference and citation; the correlation between the quality of reference and citation. Through the study, neither of the two aspects is obvious. So the correlation between reference and citation is not obvious, reference should be an index of paper evaluation system, independent of the citation indicator.
关键词
论文评价 /
被引频次 /
参考文献的数量 /
参考文献的质量 /
评价指标
Key words
paper evaluation /
citation /
quantity of reference /
quality of reference /
evaluation inde
{{custom_sec.title}}
{{custom_sec.title}}
{{custom_sec.content}}
参考文献
[1] Virgo JA, A statistical procedure for evaluating importance of scientific papers [J].Library Quarterly,1977,47(4):415-430.
[2] 邱均平,缪雯婷. h指数在人才评价中的应用——以图书情报学领域中国学者为例[J].科学观察,2007,2(3):17-22. Qiu Jun-ping,Miao Wenting.Application of h -index in evaluating individual's performances [J].Science Focus,2007,2(3):17-22.
[3] 金碧辉,冯坚,朱献有,刘筱敏,张俭恭,苑玉兰.SCI期刊定量指标的国际比较[J].中国科技期刊研究,2002,13(2):89-94.Jin Bi-hui,Peng Jian,Zhu Xianyou,Liu Xiaomin.Zhang Jiangong,Yuan Yulan.The international comparison of SCI journals' quantitative indicators [J].Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodical,2002,13(2):89-94.
[4] 简琳,何静,周剑.论文被引的文本因素分析: 多学科视角[J].图书情报工作,2011,55(20):32-35.Jian Lin,He Jing,Zhou Jian.Document factors inpacting on the citation of an article: multi-fields view [J].Library and Information Service,2011,55(20):32-35.
[5] Gregory D. Webster,Peter K.Jonason,Tatiana Orozco Schember. Hot topics and popular papers in evol utionary psychology: Analyses of title words and citation counts in evolution and human behavior,1979-2008[J].Evolutionary Psychology,2009,7(3):348-362.
[6] 庞海波. 科技期刊参考文献的合理引用[J].编辑学报,2008,20(5):406-407.Pang Hai-bo.On reasonable citations of sci-tech periodicals[J].Acta Editologica,2008,20(5):406-407.
[7] 杨利军,万小渝. 引用习惯对我国期刊论文被引频次的影响分析——以情报学为例[J].情报科学,2012,30(7):1093-1096.Yang Li-jun, Wan Xiao-yu.The impact of cite habits to the citations of journal articles in China--A case study of information science [J].Information Science,2012,30(7):1093-1096.
基金
ISTIC-THOMSON科学计量学联合实验室开放基金资助项目(IT2011002,2011-2012年);国家自然科学基金资助项目(71003011,2011-2013年);国家社会科学基金资助项目(11BTQ021,2011-2014年).
