多主体参与的创新联合体稳定策略研究

马宗国, 蒋依晓

科研管理 ›› 2024, Vol. 45 ›› Issue (10) : 56-68.

PDF(1669 KB)
PDF(1669 KB)
科研管理 ›› 2024, Vol. 45 ›› Issue (10) : 56-68. DOI: 10.19571/j.cnki.1000-2995.2024.10.006

多主体参与的创新联合体稳定策略研究

作者信息 +

Research on the stable strategy of innovation consortium with multi-agent participation

Author information +
文章历史 +

摘要

创新联合体作为新型举国体制微观化成果,成为我国应对科技创新发展形势、构建融通创新体系和支撑产业高质量发展的重要载体。本研究基于创新联合体多主体参与模型,考虑在中央政府考核监管和公共研究组织知识创造作用下的产业链领军企业、产业链配套企业和地方政府的策略选择,构建三方演化博弈模型,求解不同情况下的演化稳定策略组合,利用李雅普诺夫第一法则分析了演化策略组合的稳定性,并运用Matlab 2022b对博弈主体在不同参量变化下的策略选择进行了仿真分析。研究结果表明:(1)产业链领军企业是影响创新联合体组建的关键内驱力,对于产业链领军企业而言,不主导创新时的招致损失和协同创新成本是影响其演化博弈结果的关键因素;(2)产业链配套企业作为创新联合体体系化创新力量,对地方政府补贴敏感度高于产业链领军企业,当产业链领军企业主导创新和地方政府补贴的概率越高,产业链配套企业越倾向加入创新联合体;(3)地方政府的支持是创新联合体前期组建的基础引领动力,中央政府对地方政府的资金倾斜力度会对地方政府演化稳定策略产生显著积极影响。最后,本文提出如下对策建议:提供精细化政策保障,增强产业链领军企业主导创新能力;实施针对性补贴支持,激发产业链配套企业内生创新动力;搭建融通合作平台,增强产业链创新活力。通过将创新联合体的关键参与主体及其相应功能定位和主体策略选择演化过程作为研究主线,进一步丰富了组建创新联合体的理论研究,系统聚焦创新联合体微观主体的策略,为创新联合体的稳定运行提供实践启示。

Abstract

Innovation consortium, representing a micro-level achievement of the new national system, has become a crucial way for China to respond to scientific and technological innovations, promote the integrated innovation and support high-quality industrial development. This paper, based on the multi-agent participation model of innovation consortium, after considering the strategic choices of leading enterprises, supporting enterprises, and government supervision departments, constructed a tripartite evolutionary game model, and solved the stable equilibrium point of each game player's strategic choice. The stability of the strategy combination was analyzed with the Lyapunov's first method, and Matlab 2022b was used for simulation analysis to verify the influence of each decision variable on the strategy choice of different players. The results showed that: first of all, the leading enterprises in the industrial chain are the key driving forces affecting the formation of innovation consortium. For the leading enterprises, the incurred loss and cost of collaborative innovation when they do not lead innovation in the innovation consortium are the key factors influencing the evolutionary game results. Secondly, the supporting enterprises in the industrial chain, as the systemic innovation subjects of innovation consortium, are more sensitive to government subsidies than the leading enterprises. With the higher probability of local government subsidies and the leading enterprises of leading innovation, they are more inclined to join the cooperation of innovation consortium. Moreover, the support of local government is the basic guiding force for the formation of innovation consortia in the early stage, and the central government's funding preference for local governments will have a positive impact on the evolution stable strategy of local governments. Finally, this paper proposed the following countermeasures: refined policies should be provided to enhance the leading innovation capabilities of the industrial chain leading enterprises; targeted subsidy should be implemented to stimulate the endogenous innovation drive of the industrial chain supporting enterprises; and integrated cooperation platforms should be established to bolster the innovation vitality of the industrial chain. Key participating entities of the innovation consortium and their corresponding functional orientations, as well as the evolutionary process of their strategic choices should be taken as the main research line to enrich the theoretical research on the formation of innovation consortia. Moreover, focuses systematically on the strategies of micro-entities in the innovation consortium will offer more practical insights into the maintenance of stability.

关键词

创新联合体 / 稳定策略 / 领军企业 / 三方演化博弈 / 仿真分析

Key words

innovation consortium / stable strategy / leading enterprise / three-party evolutionary game / simulation analysis

引用本文

导出引用
马宗国, 蒋依晓. 多主体参与的创新联合体稳定策略研究[J]. 科研管理. 2024, 45(10): 56-68 https://doi.org/10.19571/j.cnki.1000-2995.2024.10.006
Ma Zongguo, Jiang Yixiao. Research on the stable strategy of innovation consortium with multi-agent participation[J]. Science Research Management. 2024, 45(10): 56-68 https://doi.org/10.19571/j.cnki.1000-2995.2024.10.006
中图分类号: F224.32;F124.3   

参考文献

[1]
杨忠, 巫强, 宋孟璐, 等. 美国《芯片与科学法案》对我国半导体产业发展的影响及对策研究:基于创新链理论的视角[J]. 南开管理评论, 2023, 26(1):146-160.
YANG Zhong, WU Qiang, SONG Menglu, et al. Research on the impact of U.S. “CHIPS and Science Act” on China's semiconductor industry and countermeasures: From the perspective of innovation chain theory[J]. Nankai Business Review, 2023, 26(1):146-160.
[2]
陈劲, 尹西明, 陈泰伦, 等. 有组织创新:全面提升国家创新体系整体效能的战略与进路[J]. 中国软科学, 2024(3):1-14.
CHEN Jin, YIN Ximing, CHEN Tailun, et al. Organized innovation: Strategy and insights on improving overall efficiency of the national innovation system[J]. China Soft Science, 2024(3):1-14.
[3]
赵晶, 刘玉洁, 付珂语, 等. 大型国企发挥产业链链长职能的路径与机制:基于特高压输电工程的案例研究[J]. 管理世界, 2022, 38(5):221-240.
ZHAO Jing, LIU Yujie, FU Keyu, et al. The path and mechanism for large state-owned enterprises to play the function of industry chain leader: A case study based on UHV transmission project[J]. Journal of Management World, 2022, 38(5):221-240.
[4]
孙冰梅, 尹西明, 陈劲, 等. 同题共答:创新联合体驱动关键核心技术持续突破的机制研究:以之江实验室为例[J/OL]. 南开管理评论:1-21[2024-07-17]. 954-966 http://kns.cnki.net/kcms/detail/12.1288.f.20240516.1926.013.html.):954-966.
SUN Bingmei, YIN Ximing, CHEN Jin, et al. Co-innovation for shared mission: The mechanism of innovation consortium driving key core technology breakthroughs: Case study based on Zhejiang lab[J/OL]. Nankai Business Review: 1-21[2024-07-17]. 954-966 http://kns.cnki.net/kcms/detail/12.1288.f.20240516.1926.013.html.):954-966.
[5]
穆荣平, 郭京京, 康瑾, 等. 制造业开放创新趋势、问题和政策建议[J]. 中国科学院院刊, 2022, 37(7):954-966.
MU Rongping, GUO Jingjing, KANG Jin, et al. Open innovation trends, issues and policy suggestions in manufacturing industry[J]. Bulletin of Chinese Academy of Sciences, 2022, 37(7):954-966.
[6]
尹西明, 孙冰梅, 袁磊, 等. 科技自立自强视角下企业共建创新联合体的机制研究[J/OL]. 科学学与科学技术管理:1-20[2024-07-17]. http://kns.cnki.net/kcms/detail/12.1117.G3.20230613.1808.002.html.
YIN Ximing, SUN Bingmei, YUAN Lei, et al. Research on the mechanism of innovation consortium co-constructed by enterprise from S&T self-reliance and self-improvement perspective[J/OL]. Science of Science and Management of S.&T.:1-20[2024-07-17]. http://kns.cnki.net/kcms/detail/12.1117.G3.20230613.1808.002.html.
[7]
高茜滢, 吴慈生, 王琦. 基于合作竞争与协同创新的创新联合体研究[J]. 中国软科学, 2022, 383(11):155-164.
GAO Qianying, WU Cisheng, WANG Qi. Research on innovation consortium based on cooperative competition and collaborative innovation[J]. China Soft Science, 2022, 383(11):155-164.
[8]
叶伟巍, 黄淑芳. 企业牵头组建创新联合体的三阶段动态模型[J]. 科学学研究, 2024, 42(9):2010-2016.
摘要
创新联合体,是新型举国体制的战略支点;企业牵头,是组建创新联合体的重要途径。如何构建“利益融合、要素融通、能力融汇”创新联合体,从而推动创新链和产业链深度耦合,是新形势下创新型国家建设过程中所面临的重大研究话题。本文通过案例分析法,解析企业牵头组建创新联合体五个管理环节和机制特征,据此构建三阶段动态演化模型。研究发现:(1)企业战略更新,是创新联合体的动力源泉;(2)二元组织架构,是两链耦合的关系支点;(3)实物期权思维,有利于激励兼容的利益融合;(4)交互学习机制,是要素融通的过程要津;(5)数字赋能手段,是能力融汇的重要支撑。本文构建创新联合体三阶段演化模型,解析创新链和产业链深度耦合的动态过程和管理思路,旨在为深陷红海竞争的传统企业提供稳进提质解决方案,从而全面安全推动科技自立自强和产业自主可控。
YE Weiwei, HUANG Shufang. A three-stage dynamic model of firm-led innovation consortia[J]. Studies in Science of Science, 2024, 42(9):2010-2016.
Innovation consortium is the strategic linchpin of the new national system, and the leadership of enterprises is an important way to form innovation consortium. How to build an innovation consortium with "fusion of interests, integration of elements and convergence of capabilities" to promote the deep coupling of innovation and industrial chains is an important research topic in the process of building an innovative country under the new situation. In this paper, we analyzed the characteristics of five management linkages and mechanisms of enterprise-led innovation consortia through case studies, and constructed a three-stage dynamic evolution model accordingly. It was found that: (1) corporate strategy renewal is the driving force of the innovation consortium; (2) binary organizational structure is the fulcrum of the relationship between the two chains; (3) real option thinking is conducive to incentive-compatible interest integration; (4) interactive learning mechanism is the key to the process of factor integration; (5) digital empowerment is the important support of capability integration. This paper constructs a three-stage evolutionary model of innovation consortium, analyzes the dynamic process and management ideas of deep coupling of innovation and industrial chains. Then aims to provide stable solutions for traditional enterprises in deep red sea competition, so as to comprehensively and safely promote S&T self-sufficiency and industrial autonomy.
[9]
王巍, 陈劲, 尹西明, 等. 高水平研究型大学驱动创新联合体建设的探索:以中国西部科技创新港为例[J]. 科学学与科学技术管理, 2022, 43(4):21-39.
WANG Wei, CHEN Jin, YIN Ximing, et al. Innovation consortium construction driven by high-level research university: A case study of western China science and technology innovation harbour[J]. Science of Science and Management of S.&T., 2022, 43(4):21-39.
[10]
尹西明, 陈泰伦, 陈劲, 等. 面向科技自立自强的高能级创新联合体建设[J]. 陕西师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版), 2022, 51(2):51-60.
YIN Ximing, CHEN Tailun, CHEN Jin, et al. High-level innovation consortium for S&T self-reliance and self-improvement[J]. Journal of Shaanxi Normal University (Philosophy and Social Sciences Edition), 2022, 51(2):51-60.
[11]
冯南平, 向巧, 沈荣骏, 等. 航空发动机关键核心技术攻关的组织策略研究[J]. 中国工程科学, 2022, 24(4):222-229.
摘要
尽快突破航空发动机产业的关键核心技术是保障国家战略安全的迫切需求,创新力量的有效组织成为关键核心技术攻关实践中亟待解决的瓶颈问题。本文梳理了我国航空发动机科研生产体系中的创新主体构成现状,剖析了实施协同创新面临的迫切问题;进一步阐明了航空发动机关键核心技术攻关过程中各主体的角色定位,涵盖政府、军队、中国航发、专业化维修企业、上 / 下游企业、高校和科研院所等。研究认为,统筹安排并科学布局关键核心技术攻关工作、设计相应制度与机制以引导激励各类主体主动对接国家战略、重视需求侧对技术发展的牵引作用、由领军企业主导构建一批面向用户需求与产品问题的创新联合体、以重大项目为载体构建创新生态系统,由此高效组织各类主体协同攻关航空发动机关键核心技术。
FENG Nanping, XIANG Qiao, SHEN Rongjun, et al. Organization strategies of innovation forces for the breakthrough of key core technologies in aero-engine industry[J]. Strategic Study of CAE, 2022, 24(4):222-229.

Achieving breakthroughs of key core technologies in the aero-engine industry is urgently required for guaranteeing national strategic security, and it demands effective organization of innovation forces. This study first analyses the major innovation forces and their problems regarding collaborative innovation in the current aero-engine scientific research and production system in China. Subsequently, it clarifies the roles of relevant forces in the research process of key core technologies, including the government, the army, the Aero Engine Corporation of China, professional maintenance enterprises, upstream and downstream enterprises, universities, and research institutes. Furthermore, we suggest that the breakthrough practice should be planned and organized in an overall manner, corresponding institutions and mechanisms should be created to encourage the innovation forces to closely align with national strategies, the driving role of the demand side should be emphasized, a number of innovation consortia aiming at user needs and product problems should be established by leading enterprises, and an innovation ecosystem should be established relying on major projects.

[12]
郭菊娥, 王梦迪, 冷奥琳. 企业布局搭建创新联合体重塑创新生态的机理与路径研究[J]. 西安交通大学学报(社会科学版), 2022, 42(1):76-84.
GUO Ju'e, WANG Mengdi, LENG Aolin. The mechanism and path of enterprise reshaping innovation ecology by building innovation consortiums[J]. Journal of Xi'an Jiaotong University (Social Sciences), 2022, 42(1):76-84.
[13]
张羽飞, 原长弘, 张树满. 共建产学研创新联合体对科技中小企业创新绩效的影响研究[J]. 管理学报, 2023, 20(1):76-85.
ZHANG Yufei, YUAN Changhong, ZHANG Shuman. Research on the influence of co-founding industry-university-research innovation entities on high-tech SMEs' innovation performance[J]. Chinese Journal of Management, 2023, 20(1):76-85.
[14]
吴晓波, 张馨月, 沈华杰. 商业模式创新视角下我国半导体产业“突围”之路[J]. 管理世界, 2021, 37(3):123-136+9.
WU Xiaobo, ZHANG Xinyue, SHEN Huajie. Business model innovation perspective on how could China's semiconductor industry to break out the blocks[J]. Journal of Management World, 2021, 37(3):123-136+9.
[15]
周艳芳, 顾青瑶. 智慧集群平台赋能高水平研究型大学创新联合体建设的内在机理与优化路径[J]. 中国科技论坛, 2024(1):16-26.
ZHOU Yanfang, GU Qingyao. The internal mechanism and optimization path of the construction of innovative consortia of high-level research universities enabled by the smart cluster platform[J]. Forum on Science and Technology in China, 2024(1):16-26.
[16]
郭淑芬, 任学娜. 科技自立自强背景下使命驱动型创新过程模式:基于我国传统制造业关键核心技术突破的案例考察[J]. 科学学与科学技术管理, 2023, 44(10):44-62.
GUO Shufen, REN Xuena. Mission-oriented innovation process model in the context of S&T self-reliance and self-improvement: A longitudinal case study of key core technology breakthrough in China's traditional manufacturing industry[J]. Science of Science and Management of S.&T., 2023, 44(10):44-62.
[17]
白京羽, 刘中全, 王颖婕. 基于博弈论的创新联合体动力机制研究[J]. 科研管理, 2020, 41(10):105-113.
BAI Jingyu, LIU Zhongquan, WANG Yingjie. A research on the dynamic mechanism of innovation consortium based on the game theory[J]. Science Research Management, 2020, 41(10):105-113.
[18]
岳颖初, 霍国庆. 创新联合体利益主体间的利益冲突及博弈研究[J]. 科学学研究, 2024, 42(5):1088-1097+1120.
摘要
创新联合体是我国落实创新驱动发展战略的重要举措,其利益主体的多元化及其利益诉求的复杂性导致各方在创新协作中不可避免地存在着利益冲突,增加了利益整合与平衡的难度,影响了创新联合体的发展。为此,本文应用冲突理论、博弈论等对创新联合体利益冲突的本质和机理进行分析,归纳提出了规则性利益冲突、关系性利益冲突、分配性利益冲突三类冲突,并根据多边讨价还价博弈理论、正态分布函数、Shapley值法等构建了创新联合体利益分配过程的数学模型,对该过程不同环节产生的各类利益冲突进行量化评估,进而选取典型案例从实践层面对上述理论模型进行实证检验,最后提出了有效均衡创新联合体各方利益关系的策略建议,主要包括建立有利于共同治理的有效治理结构、促进以增强互信为核心的创新文化建设以及强化基于动态管理的激励约束措施。
YUE Yingchu, HUO Guoqing. Research on the interest conflicts and game between the stakeholders of innovation consortium[J]. Studies in Science of Science, 2024, 42(5):1088-1097+1120.
Innovation Consortium is an important factor to build the national innovation system. However, the diversity of stakeholders and the complexity of their interest demands lead to inevitable conflicts of interest in innovation collaboration, thus increasing the difficulty of interest integration and equilibrium, and affects the development of the Innovation Consortium. Therefore, this paper applies conflict theory and game theory to analyze the essence and mechanism of the conflict of interest in the Innovation Consortium, summarizes and brings up three types of conflicts: rule-based interest conflicts, relational interest conflicts, and distributive interest conflicts. Then, using theoretical methods such as multilateral bargaining game theory, normal distribution function, Shapley value method to construct a mathematical model of the interest distribution process of the Innovation Consortium, quantitatively evaluates various conflicts of interest in different parts of the process, and opting for a typical case to testify to the theoretical analysis. Finally, the paper puts forward some suggestions on how to balance the interests of all parties in the Innovation Consortium, including establishing an effective governance structure conducive to joint governance, promoting the construction of the culture of innovation, which has a core of enhancing mutual trust, as well as strengthening incentive and constraint measures based on dynamic management.
[19]
靳瑞杰, 江旭. 高校科技成果转化“路在何方”?: 基于过程性视角的转化渠道研究[J]. 科学学与科学技术管理, 2019, 40(12):35-57.
JIN Ruijie, JIANG Xu. Which way out? A process-based perspective on university technology transfer channels[J]. Science of Science and Management of S.&T., 2019, 40(12):35-57.
[20]
王珍愚, 王宁, 单晓光. 创新3.0阶段我国科技创新实践问题研究[J]. 科学学与科学技术管理, 2021, 42(4):127-141.
WANG Zhenyu, WANG Ning, SHAN Xiaoguang. Research on the practice of science and technology innovation in China at the stage of innovation[J]. Science of Science and Management of S.&T., 2021, 42(4):127-141.
[21]
刘亚婕, 董锋. 政府参与下新能源汽车企业间协同创新的竞合策略研究[J]. 研究与发展管理, 2022, 34(5):136-148.
LIU Yajie, DONG Feng. Co-opetition strategy of collaborative innovation for new energy automobile enterprises under government participation[J]. R&D Management, 2022, 34(5):136-148.
[22]
FRIEDMAN D. Evolutionary games in economics[J]. Econometrica, 1991, 59(3):637-666.
[23]
EGHBALI M A, BARZOKI M A, SAFARZADEH S. A hybrid evolutionary game-theoretic and system dynamics approach for analysis of implementation strategies of green technological innovation under government intervention[J]. Technology in Society, 2022, 70:102039.
[24]
朱立龙, 荣俊美, 张思意. 政府奖惩机制下药品安全质量监管三方演化博弈及仿真分析[J]. 中国管理科学, 2021, 29(11):55-67.
摘要
药品安全关乎人民群众生命健康、经济发展、社会稳定和国家安全,一直以来都是政府和全社会关注的热点问题之一。但是,近年来频发的各类药品安全事件,揭露了政府监管缺失、药品检测机制不完善、公众投诉失效等诸多问题。本文考虑了药品检测中存在寻租现象,构建了药品生产企业、第三方药品检测机构和政府监管部门之间的三方演化博弈模型,分析了各参与方策略选择的演化稳定性,探讨了各要素对三方策略选择的影响关系,进一步分析了三方博弈系统中均衡点的稳定性。研究结果表明:1)政府增强奖励、惩罚力度均有助于促进企业生产高药效药品、第三方药品检测机构拒绝寻租的规范行为,但是增大奖励力度将不利于政府自身履行监管职责;2)政府设定合理的奖惩机制必须符合对各方的奖惩之和大于其投机收益的条件,才能保障演化稳定市场环境下的药品安全;3)上级政府对监管部门失职的问责对增强企业生产高药效药品的稳健性具有重要意义;4)提升企业的药品销售收益、增加企业寻租成本也是避免企业生产低药效药品的有效途径。最后,利用Matlab 2020b进行了仿真分析,为政府完善药品监管机制提出了对策与建议。
ZHU Lilong, RONG Junmei, ZHANG Siyi. Three-party evolutionary game and simulation analysis of drug quality supervision under the government reward and punishment mechanism[J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science, 2021, 29(11):55-67.
Drug safety concerns the people’s life and health, economic development, social stability and national security. It has always been one of the hot issues that the government and the whole society are focusing on. However, in recent years, various drug safety incidents have been frequently reported, which have revealed many problems such as the lacking of government supervision, imperfect drug testing mechanisms. In recent years, the rapid development of third-party drug testing institutions has not only supplemented government supervision, but also provided technical support for pharmaceutical manufacturers. However, driven by interests, there are phenomena of rent-seeking in drug testing between pharmaceutical manufacturing enterprises and the third-party testing agencies. In order to study how to improve the drug quality supervision mechanism to ensure the quality of drugs and avoid rent-seeking in the process of drug testing, a three-party evolutionary game model among drug manufacturers, third-party drug testing institutions and government regulatory agencies has been constructed. Based on the three-party evolutionary game theory, the evolutionary stability of each participant's strategy choices has been analyzed, the influence of each factor on the choice of three-party strategy has been discussed, and the stability of the equilibrium points in the three-party game system has been further analyzed using Jacobian matrix and Lyapunov’s indirect method. The main results show that: 1) increased incentives and penalties by the government will help enterprises to produce high-efficiency drugs and third-party drug testing institutions to refuse to seek rent, but, increased incentives will not be conducive to the government's own performance of regulatory responsibilities; 2) in order to guarantee the safety of drugs in an evolutionarily stable market environment, the government should set reasonable reward and punishment mechanisms in line with the conditions that the sum of the rewards and punishments of each party is greater than its speculative income, that is the condition that the system has only one evolutionary stable equilibrium point; 3) the accountability of the superior government for the dereliction of duty of the regulatory authorities is of great significance to enhance the stability of enterprises in producing high-efficiency drugs; 4) enhancing the company’s drug sales revenue and increasing the company’s rent-seeking cost are also effective ways to avoid enterprises producing low-efficiency drugs. In addition, the parameters are assigned to numerical values based on the conditions of the evolutionary stability strategies which obtained by the model analysis and combined with the reality. The influence of each element on the evolution of each party’s strategy and the stability of the game system under different conditions has been simulated using the Matlab 2020b software. The simulation analysis verifies the correctness of the model analysis and the effectiveness of the countermeasures and suggestions for improving the government supervision mechanism. In short, this paper puts forward a variety of measures to ensure the stable production of high-effective drugs in enterprises and to eliminate rent-seeking, which is conducive to improving the government’s regulatory strategy to ensure patients’ medication safety.
[25]
FRIEDMAN D. On economic applications of evolutionary game theory[J]. Journal of Evolutionary Economics, 1998, 8(1):15-43.
[26]
闫晓勇, 李烨, 王刘伟, 等. 基于三方演化博弈的创新生态系统自组织集聚机制研究[J]. 科学学与科学技术管理, 2023, 44(3):63-79.
YAN Xiaoyong, LI Ye, WANG Liuwei, et al. Self-organizing agglomeration mechanism of innovation ecosystem based on tripartite evolutionary game[J]. Science of Science and Management of S.&T., 2023, 44(3):63-79.

基金

国家社会科学基金重点项目:“基于研究联合体的国家自主创新示范区产业转型升级”(21AGL035)
国家社会科学基金重点项目:“基于研究联合体的国家自主创新示范区产业转型升级”(2021.09—2024.12)

PDF(1669 KB)

Accesses

Citation

Detail

段落导航
相关文章

/