科研管理 ›› 2023, Vol. 44 ›› Issue (3): 33-42.

• 论文 • 上一篇    下一篇

《科研管理》前沿选题征文分析及与国际研究的对比述评

张璐1,卢叶1,王萍2   

  1. 1.内蒙古工业大学经济管理学院,内蒙古 呼和浩特010051;
    2.中国科学院科技战略咨询研究院,北京100190

  • 收稿日期:2021-09-17 修回日期:2022-03-29 出版日期:2023-03-20 发布日期:2023-03-20
  • 通讯作者: 王萍
  • 基金资助:
    国家社会科学基金重大项目(21&ZD134);国家自然科学基金项目(71962027;72162028);内蒙古自然科学基金杰青项目(2021JQ08)。

Analysis of frontier topics and essays in Science Research Management and comparison with international studies example

Zhang Lu1, Lu Ye1, Wang Ping2   

  1. 1. School of Economics and Management, Inner Mongolia University of Technology, Hohhot 010051, Inner Mongolia, China;
    2. Institutes of Science and Development, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, China
  • Received:2021-09-17 Revised:2022-03-29 Online:2023-03-20 Published:2023-03-20
  • Contact: wang ping

摘要:     《科研管理》作为管理科学领域的重要学术交流平台,积极响应国家最新发展战略从2018年起推出前沿选题,并持续更新选题内容以维系选题的前沿性、创新性及实践性。本文采取内容分析法系统梳理《科研管理》前沿选题征文并将其与国际研究进行对比,以期探寻提升期刊前沿选题学术影响力以及选题下学术研究成果理论与实践价值的路径。研究发现:(1)《科研管理》在深度解析国家最新发展战略基础上新增国家科技安全、区域创新生态体系建设、基础研究与原始创新能力等前沿选题,指引学者立足于我国经济社会发展中与管理科学相关的重大问题,以中国“情境”作为研究突破口,对我国面临的国家科技安全体系不完善、区域创新能力薄弱、原始创新能力不足等问题展开前瞻性分析;(2)《科研管理》充分利用我国制度优势提出的前沿选题对中国特色管理理论创新具有重要意义并取得初步进展,但其选题下的理论研究仍存在依赖于概念性引入学习、理论整合多于拓展与深入等现象,难以系统全面的分析前沿选题指向的我国经济社会发展中亟待解决的问题;(3)《科研管理》未来可以通过开设前沿选题研究专栏、搭建选题创新成果展示阵地、拓展前沿选题宣传渠道等多种方式加强选题与选题下高质量研究成果的分享与传播,吸引更多学者了解并全面深入剖析前沿选题,引导学者将我国独特的情境特征嵌入于研究设计,析出具有学术价值的原创性管理理论回应并服务于国家战略发展需求。

关键词: 科研管理, 前瞻性研究, 前沿选题, 本土情境, 管理科学

Abstract:     As an important academic exchange platform in the field of management science, Science Research Management has launched frontier topics since 2018 in line with the domestic and international situation, and responded actively to the latest development strategy of the country, which has continuously added topics that are frontier, innovative and practical. This paper adopts the content analysis method to systematically sort out the front topic selection solicitation of Science Research Management, and compares it with international research, in order to explore the path to improve the academic influence of frontier topic selection and the value of academic research results under topic selection, so as to put forward the future development direction and suggestions of the journal. The findings are as follows: (1) Based on the in-depth analysis of the latest national development strategy, Science Research Management added frontier topics such as national scientific and technological security, regional innovation ecosystem construction, basic research and original innovation ability, guided scholars to take China′s "situation" as the basis of framework construction and research assumptions based on the urgent practical problems to be solved in China, analyzed the imperfect national scientific and technological security system, weak regional innovation ability and carried out a forward-looking analysis on problems such as insufficient original innovation ability. (2) The frontier topics proposed by Science Research Management, which makes full use of China′s institutional advantages, are of great significance to the innovation of management theory with Chinese characteristics. However, the research results under the topic did not fully achieve the research goal of building a perfect theoretical system based on the situation with Chinese characteristics. The first reason is that the practice and problems of management with Chinese characteristics are complex and diverse, and it is difficult to condense the theory to meet the requirements of science and universality as well as Chinese characteristics. Secondly, the existing research of Science Research Management mainly takes the western theory as the underlying structure to support the development of the localization theory system, and less considers the elements with Chinese characteristics. However, compared with the western countries, the embedded national situation, social culture and institutional environment of China′s enterprise innovation management practice are different, so the existing theoretical basis lacks a certain fit with the management practice with Chinese characteristics. (3) In the future, on the one hand, Science Research Management can strengthen the sharing and dissemination of frontier topics and high-quality research results by expanding the publicity channels of frontier topics, setting up research columns on frontier topics, and building display positions for innovative results of topics, so as to attract more scholars to understand and comprehensively and deeply analyze the major problems related to management science in the development process of China behind frontier topics. At the same time, guiding scholars to build a perfect and more national characteristic management innovation theoretical system based on China′s national conditions and enterprise characteristic management practice to guide the development of local enterprises. On the other hand, Science Research Management still needs to go deeper into the local institutional environment and cultural background, and dig out topics that are more of China′s practical significance and can fully reflect the times and frontier nature of academic research. At the same time, Science Research Management is supposed to constantly improve the quality of topics and guide scholars to embed China′s unique situational characteristics into research design, so as to provide original management theory support with academic value for the high-quality innovation and development of local enterprises. Although there are shortcomings in this paper, the more important significance lies in, on the one hand, analyzing the frontier topics of Science Research Management and the current situation of academic research under international related topics, clarifying the differences in research direction between domestic and foreign scholars under the guidance of different situations, and inspiring more scholars to realize that China′s unique institutional situation can give birth to a theoretical system with more characteristics of China′s national conditions, thus attracting scholars to embed China′s unique situation characteristics into research designs. On the other hand, combined with the Chinese situation, this paper puts forward the research prospect, guides scholars to pay attention to the emerging new problems and phenomena, takes the practical problems to be solved in China as the research breakthrough, and provides constantly the frontier theory rooted in Chinese management practice for the field of Chinese management science.

Key words: Science Research Management, forward-looking research, frontier topics, local situation, management science