科研管理 ›› 2022, Vol. 43 ›› Issue (12): 1-13.

• 论文 •    下一篇

基于创新生态系统的水电工程技术标准国际化路径——英国标准协会(BSI)案例研究

唐震1,2,3,张露1,2,3,张阳1,2,3   

  1. 1. 河海大学商学院,江苏 南京211000;
    2.江苏省“‘世界水谷’与水生态文明”协同创新中心,江苏 南京211000;
    3. 江苏省决策咨询研究基地(企业国际化发展),江苏 南京211000

  • 收稿日期:2019-11-28 修回日期:2020-07-09 出版日期:2022-12-20 发布日期:2022-12-21
  • 通讯作者: 唐震
  • 基金资助:
    国家社会科学基金面上项目:“中国水电工程技术标准‘走出去’竞争模式、治理机制与对策研究”(16BGL013,2016.10—2019.12);国家社会科学基金重大项目:“中国与湄公河流域国家环境利益共同体建设研究”(16ZDA046,2016.11—2021.11);中央高校基本科研业务费资助项目(2017B18214,2017.03—2021.03);中央高校基本科研业务费资助项目(B210207033,2021.03—2022.12)。

The internationalization path of hydroelectric engineering technical standards based on the innovation ecosystem: A case study of BSI

Tang Zhen1,2,3, Zhang Lu1,2,3, Zhang Yang1,2,3   

  1. 1. Business School, Hohai University, Nanjing 211000, Jiangsu, China; 
    2. Collaborative Innovation Center of World Water Valley and Water Ecological Civilization, Nanjing 211000, Jiangsu, China; 
    3. Jiangsu Decision Consulting Research Base / Internationalized Development of Enterprises, Nanjing 211000, Jiangsu, China
  • Received:2019-11-28 Revised:2020-07-09 Online:2022-12-20 Published:2022-12-21

摘要:    技术标准主导权深刻影响着全球治理的格局与制度安排。“中国水电”“走出去”是中国践行全球治理中国理念和中国方案的重要非正式机制之一,中国水电工程无论是技术水平还是市场份额都位居世界领先,但仍严重受制于欧美国际主流工程技术标准,影响中国在全球治理体系中大国作用的发挥,这对探索中国水电工程技术标准国际化的可行模式和有效路径提出迫切要求。与此同时,欧美国际主流工程技术标准都经历了由国内规范至国际标准成功转化的过程,其中,世界标准之源——英国标准协会(BSI)在英国水电工程技术标准国际化过程中发挥举足轻重的作用,其内在逻辑值得探究与借鉴。因此,本文基于创新生态系统理论、角色理论及技术标准扩散理论,遵循“动因-行为-结果”的逻辑主线对BSI进行案例研究,深入剖析英国水电工程技术标准国际化驱动因素、模式及其演化路径等内在规律,并在中英水电工程技术标准对比基础上,对中国水电工程技术标准“走出去”提出切实可行的对策建议。

关键词: 英国标准协会(BSI), 水电工程技术标准, 创新生态系统, 国际化路径

Abstract:    The dominance of technical standards has a profound impact on the pattern and institutional arrangement of global governance. Sino-hydro internationalization is one of the most important informal mechanisms to practicing Chinese concept of global governance. China′s hydroelectric project takes the leading position in the world both in technology and market but is still subject to European and American engineering technical standards, which influence Chinese major role in global governance system. Current situation urgently requests to explore the feasible mode and effective path of Chinese hydroelectric engineering technical standards internationalization. Meanwhile, international mainstream engineering technical standards have undergone a successful transformation from domestic norms to international standards. Among them, British Standards Institution plays a pivotal role in the process of internationalization of British hydroelectric engineering technical standards. Due to this fact, based on the theory of innovation ecosystem, role theory and technical standard diffusion theory, this study tends to investigate the evolution of British standards by identifying the roles and strategic actions of system members, analyzing the competitive advantage of the system. Based on the longitudinal development history of British Standards Institution, this exploratory single-case study would make an in-depth description and theoretical explanation of British Standards Institution, untangle the mode of hydroelectric engineering technical standard internationalization.It comes to the following findings: first, with the change in dynamic environment, different organizations play diverse roles and then perform strategic actions in three stages. The essence of role transformation is that members of innovation system cope with environment change, system evolution and members′ behaviors, following with the change of strategic actions, generating characteristic modes. Second, three characteristic modes include technology standardization, technical standards internationalization and technical standard business internationalization, forming three advantages involving standard leading, network effect and positive feedback of standard. Third, on account of comparison between China and Britain, this study puts forward suggestions from three levels containing collaborative innovation-led technology standardization, technical standards internationalization based on industrial alliances and ecosystem competition centered on hydroelectric engineering technical standards. To be specific, British hydroelectric engineering technical standard embedded in the innovation ecosystem establish high switching cost, resulting in technical standards competition turning to competition in technical standards innovation ecosystem. The possibility of new technical standards replacing current standards depends on innovation ecosystem whether can provide the same or more full-featured environmental conditions and service functions. Hence, the new innovation ecosystem should not only integrate the current ecosystem but also achieve better performance on this basis.This paper makes main contributions as follows: first, it tends to bridge the gap in the role theory with the attempt to observe the dynamic evolution of organizational roles; second, it constructs a technical standard innovation ecosystem based on national and international competitive advantage at macro-level, analyzes members′ relationship at meso-level, discusses how a core member drive the evolution of system members at micro-level. Further, the view of supporting role of government and association in innovation ecosystem proposed in this paper can enrich the existing research about ecosystem; third, it deepens the comprehension of reason that European and American enterprises have been rarely involved in hydropower construction but their technical standards can still occupy a dominant position in the world, emphasize that technical standards is a key competitive advantage for hydroelectric engineering enterprises and even the country.

Key words: British Standards Institution (BSI), hydroelectric engineering technical standards, innovation ecosystem, internationalization path