科研管理 ›› 2020, Vol. 41 ›› Issue (10): 40-53.

• 论文 • 上一篇    下一篇

企业税收激励对R&D投资的影响机理及效应——时间趋势、效力边界与创新产出

刘井建,赵革新,李惠竹   

  1. 大连理工大学经济管理学院,辽宁 大连116024
  • 收稿日期:2017-08-16 修回日期:2018-06-06 出版日期:2020-10-20 发布日期:2020-10-19
  • 通讯作者: 刘井建
  • 基金资助:
     国家社会科学基金资助重大项目:“‘一带一路’国家资金融通机制设计及资金配置效率评价体系研究”(18ZDA095,2018.01—2022.12);辽宁省社科规划基金项目:“辽宁省企业税收负担变动对R&D投资及其产出的边际影响研究”(L17BGL016,2016.01—2017.12);中央高校基本科研业务费资助项目:“中国上市公司金融化对实业投资的影响机理及效应”(DUT19RW119,2019.01—2020.12) 。

Influence mechanism and effect of corporate tax incentives on R&D investment
—Time trend, effective boundary and innovation output

 Liu Jingjian, Zhao Gexin, Li Huizhu   

  1.  School of Economics and Management, Dalian University of Technology, Dalian 116024, Liaoning, China
  • Received:2017-08-16 Revised:2018-06-06 Online:2020-10-20 Published:2020-10-19
  • Supported by:
     

摘要: 通过构建企业股东和外部投资者的代理模型发现,企业税收激励降低了R&D投资的必要收益率或融资成本,有助于提高R&D投资和创新产出,研发加计扣除政策具有价值引导和共同激励的双重效应。针对在2007~2015年披露研发信息的上市公司数据,面板回归结果发现:我国企业实际所得税税率呈现下降趋势,R&D投资呈现上升趋势;企业税收激励对R&D投资的作用是有效力边界的,在低税率和高研发强度的区域激励效应显著,在高税率或低研发强度的区域影响效应较弱;企业税收激励对创新产出的促进作用主要是通过提高研发强度实现的。研究结论对厘清政策机制效应、促进企业R&D投资以及激发创新活力提供了理论与经验支持。

 

Abstract:

In the background of the gradual economy recovery from the financial crisis, economic development in China is still in a period of superposition and transition, and the key to solving development problems lies in innovation. The tax burden of enterprises is an important factor affecting economic development. At the same time, the corporate tax burden became a hot topic at that time, and the corporate tax burden was an important factor affecting economic development. In 2017, when the supply-side structural reform deepened, China would further implement the policy of tax reduction and fee reduction. The higher tax burden reduces the expected income and raises the financing cost, which is especially bad for enterprises′ innovation. How to stimulate R&D investment through tax policies has also become a competitive activity practiced by the government.
In order to promote R&D investment, the Chinese government has issued a series of tax incentives. Among them, the pre-tax deduction policy on R&D expenses is the most impressive, and it has played an active guiding role in promoting scientific and technological innovation of enterprises, upgrading industrial structure, and building an innovative country. In 2006, the Ministry of Finance and the State Administration of Taxation(SAT) carried out the "Notice on Preferential Corporate Income Tax Policies on Enterprise Technological Innovation". Except for full deduction for businesses′ R&D expenses, it is allowed extra 50% deduction in the current year before the enterprise income tax. In 2008, with the reform of tax, the SAT has clarified the definition of R&D activities, but mainly for high-tech enterprises, and then it expanded the accounting extent in 2013. In 2016, the range of benefit object was expanded to resident enterprises that have sound accounting, conduct auditing and collection, and can accurately collect R&D expenses. Since corporate income tax is the basis for the extra deduction of R&D expenses, it not only directly affects the retained earnings of reinvestment, but also affects the motivation and intensity of R&D investment. Therefore, it is particularly important to reveal the mechanism and effect of corporate tax incentives affecting R&D investment.
Considering the existing research, there are still some limitations. First, few studies have analyzed the mechanism of corporate tax incentives on R&D investment from the perspective of financial decision-making, such as capital costs, required return and owned capital. Therefore, it is necessary to conduct research on the financial decision-making path of corporate tax incentives on R&D investment. Second, the relevant research mainly focuses on the impact of corporate tax incentives on the "quantity" of R&D investment, but there is little discussion on the "quality" of innovation output, that is, whether tax incentive improves innovation output due to the increase of R&D investment or efficiency?
This paper analysis how tax incentives affect R&D investment through multiple paths. First, tax incentives can help reduce the capital cost of R&D investment, increase the company′s after-tax profits, and mobilize the enthusiasm of the company′s R&D investment. Second, tax incentives can increase or inject R&D investment resources, reduce the marginal cost and uncertainty of R&D efforts, and diversify R&D investment risks, which promote R&D investment. Third, tax incentives can convey a positive signal to external investors to attract external financing, which in turn helps companies obtain R&D investment resources. Finally, both expenses and capitalized expenditures in R&D investments can be regarded as non-debt tax shields, reducing corporate tax burdens. Therefore, policies such as extra deductions for businesses R&D expenses have strengthened incentives for tax avoidance.
The research expects to clarify the mechanism and effect of corporate taxation on R&D investment. First, by constructing an agency model of corporate shareholders and external investors, we reveal the transmission path of tax incentives on R&D investment in different scenarios of no tax, normal tax rate and super deduction policy, and further explore the mechanism on innovation output; Second, this paper use panel regression model to empirically analyze the effect of corporate tax incentives on R&D investment, identify effectiveness boundary conditions, and further discuss the intermediary path to innovation output.
Through constructing the agency model about corporate shareholders and external investors, this paper finds that tax incentives can lower the required rate of return and financing costs, and exhibit income effects increasing R&D investment and outputs, especially additional R&D deduction policy has dual effects of value guidance and joint incentive. Using the data of listed companies in China from 2007 to 2015, panel regression results show that: effective tax rates display a downward trend while R&D investments upward; the incentive of corporate tax on R&D investment has a boundary that is effective within the areas of low tax rates and high R&D intensity and less with others. The promoting effect of corporate tax incentives on output primarily results from R&D investment increasing. The conclusions provide references for the effectiveness of tax policies, increasing R&D investment and stimulating corporate innovation. 

Key words: effective tax rate, R&D investment, time trend, effective boundary, innovation output

中图分类号: