科研管理 ›› 2019, Vol. 40 ›› Issue (5): 233-243.

• 论文 • 上一篇    下一篇

高管政治联系对民营企业创新绩效的影响——董事会治理行为的非线性中介效应

刘美芬   

  1. 齐鲁工业大学(山东省科学院)金融学院,山东 济南250100
  • 收稿日期:2016-03-22 修回日期:2018-05-30 出版日期:2019-05-20 发布日期:2019-05-21
  • 通讯作者: 刘美芬
  • 基金资助:
     齐鲁工业大学人文社科校级规划项目:“制度嵌入视角下高管社会关系影响民营企业绩效的作用机理研究”。

Impact of top executives’ political connections on innovation performance——The nonlinear mediation effect of the board’s governance behavior#br#

Liu Meifen   

  1. School of Finance,Qilu University of Technology (Shandong Academy of Sciences), Jinan 250100, Shandong, China
  • Received:2016-03-22 Revised:2018-05-30 Online:2019-05-20 Published:2019-05-21

摘要: 创新绩效是衡量一个企业创新水平的有效标准,高管政治联系对民营企业创新绩效具有重要影响。但是高管政治联系不是直接作用于创新绩效,而是借助于董事会治理行为。本文构建了“高管政治联系→董事会治理行为→创新绩效”的作用机理模型,对2009-2013年我国深市民营上市公司3065个有效观测值采用非线性检验方法验证董事会治理行为的中介作用,研究发现:高管政治联系和董事会治理行为呈非线性倒U型关系;董事会治理行为和创新绩效呈现非线性对数关系;在高管政治联系和创新绩效间董事会治理行为具有非线性中介作用。本文研究对民营企业完善创新机制、提升创新效率以及政府制定监控政策提供借鉴和启示。

关键词: 高管政治联系, 创新绩效, 民营上市公司, 董事会治理行为, 中介效应

Abstract: Since the reform and opening up, the development of private economy has been rapid. How to maintain the momentum of growth is the key problem that private enterprises need to solve urgently. It is the core competitiveness of private enterprises to have advanced innovation technology and efficient innovation efficiency. If innovation is integrated into the production activities of enterprises, it will promote economic growth; on the contrary, if it is integrated into non-production activities such as rent-seeking, it will restrict economic growth. Therefore, innovation is a necessary condition for the enterprise's development, and innovation performance is an effective criterion to measure an enterprise's innovation level. However, innovation performance is constrained by many institutional environmental factors, such as legal environment, preferential policies of the government, financial system and so on.Whether or not enterprises have political connections may affect their innovation performance. Private enterprises with political connections can enjoy preferential policies of the government and obtain financial subsidies. Under the condition of financing constraints, it is easier to obtain the funds needed for innovation through external financing. Scholars have verified the mechanism of the relationship between executive' political connections and innovation performance, but the results are different. Some scholars believe that executive' political connections have a positive impact on enterprise R&D and can positively promote the independent innovation of enterprises; some scholars have found that executive' political connections have a significant negative impact on technological innovation performance. Scholars have inconsistent conclusions about the relationship between executive' political connections and innovation performance. The main reason is that the relationship between executive' political connections and innovation performance is directly established in the process of analysis, which leads to a larger logical jump.Based on the SCP theory of industrial organization, the characteristics of executives such as executive' political connections do not simply directly affect innovation performance, but by means of mediating effects. This paper introduces the mediating effect of the governance behavior of the board of directors when analyzing the influence ofexecutive' political connections on innovation performance, explains the formation mechanism of innovation performance from the level of the governance behavior of the board of directors, and constructs the influence path model of " executive' political connections →the governance behavior of the board of directors →innovation performance ". At the same time, the relationship between the governance behavior of the board of directors and innovation performance are not a simple linear relationship. However, there may be a non-linear relationship. This paper uses the non-linear test method to verify the intermediary role of the governance behavior of the board of directors, so as to expand the existing private enterprise innovation research.This paper puts forward three research hypotheses:executive' political connections have a non-linear impact on the governance behavior of the board of directors, that is, logarithmic or inverted U-shaped; there is a non-linear relationship between the governance behavior of the board of directors and innovation performance, that is, logarithmic or inverted U-shaped; and between executive' political connections and innovation performance, the governance behavior of the board of directors plays a non-linear intermediary effect. In this paper, 5128 observation points of non-financial private listed companies from Shenzhen Stock Exchange from 2009 to 2013 are selected as initial samples. In order to improve the representativeness of samples, according to the usual practice, 3065 valid observations were obtained by eliminating ST or ST*, the existence of abnormal values, the serious lack of data, and the rapid change of the main industry (backdoor listing) soon after listing. Financial data, governance indicators, industry classification and other information come from Xenophon database. The information of R&D investment and political contacts of senior managers is obtained by hand. The author collects the annual reports of private listed companies from the website of Shenzhen Stock Exchange to find the data of R&D investment; downloads the executive resume from the CSMAR database; if the data is missing, then searches through Sina Finance, Trend Information, the company's official website and Baidu to determine whether there are political links according to the executive resume.The study finds that executive' political connections first affect the governance behavior of the board of directors, and then affect innovation performance. The mechanism model is expanded from simple "executive' political connections→innovation performance " to" executive' political connections →the governance behavior of the board of directors →innovation performance ". Thus, the formation mechanism of executive' political connections affecting innovation performance is explained more deeply and scientifically. At present, private enterprises are often constrained by lack of funds and do not have enough funds to innovate. In this situation, executive' political linkages can improve innovation performance by means of the governance behavior of the board of directors, which can play the role of "support hand" to facilitate corporate financing and reduce financing constraints. However, the cost of establishing political linkages is high. The role of the "hand of plunder" is prominent, the burden of enterprises is increased, the funds used for innovation or other investments are greatly reduced, and executive political linkages will have a negative impact on innovation performance through the governance behavior of the board of directors. Therefore, executive' political connections have a non-linear impact on the governance behavior of the board of directors, i.e. inverted U-shaped; there is a non-linear relationship between the governance behavior of the board of directors and innovation performance, i.e. logarithmic relationship; and between executive' political connections and innovation performance, the governance behavior of the board of directors plays a non-linear intermediary effect.The conclusion of this paper has some enlightenment for perfecting corporate governance theory and application practice: firstly, in private listed companies, executive's political connection affects innovation performance through the governance behavior of the board of directors. This is an imperfect performance of the internal governance structure of the company, resulting in low efficiency of governance. Therefore, in order to sustain the development of private listed companies, we should improve the governance system, supervise and control the executives in real time, strengthen internal governance, use funds appropriately and reasonably, optimize the allocation of resources, and actively participate in innovative activities. secondly, the government should formulate regulatory measures according to the actual situation of private listed companies. In the long term, the government functional departments should simplify administrative functions, optimize the investment environment of enterprises, better serve the development of enterprises, allow market participants to participate in market competition freely and fairly, and ensure the healthy development of private listed companies.

Key words:  top executives&rsquo, political connection, innovation performance, private listed companies, governance behavior, mediation effect